Incident Details
- Date of Incident
- January 20, 2020
- Location
- La Mesa, California
- Targets
- Dan Plante (KUSI-TV)
- Assailant
- Private individual
- Was the journalist targeted?
- Yes
Assault
Several news crews were on scene when a La Mesa, California, store owner broke a Univision video camera and accosted this KUSI News cameraman and other journalists.
California man sentenced after altercation with reporter
The man involved in an altercation with KUSI-TV reporter Dan Plante and other journalists who were attempting to interview him in La Mesa, California, was sentenced on March 10, 2021, on charges related to the incident, a clerk at the San Diego Superior Court told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker.
Plante and cameraman Michael Saucedo were stationed in front of a men’s apparel store owned by Peter G. Carzis in the San Diego suburb in January 2020. They were among a group of journalists there to interview Carzis about allegations he had engaged in lewd and inappropriate behavior.
Carzis approached journalist Claudia Buccio, who was capturing footage of the store for Univision, and pushed her, then grabbed her camera and smashed it on the ground. Plante intervened and Carzis rushed both him and Saucedo, as Plante shot video of the incident on his cellphone.
Carzis attempted to hit and kick Plante multiple times and cut Plante’s nose with a piece of jewelry he was wearing, Plante said.
Plante then called 911 and Carzis was arrested the next day. He later pleaded guilty to felony vandalism and was sentenced to two years of probation, including a recommendation that he seek outpatient substance abuse treatment, and was credited for 13 days served in jail and fined $245. He was also ordered to pay restitution but the amount has not yet been specified. Three battery charges and one charge for lewd conduct against him were dismissed.
A La Mesa, California, business owner was arrested after altercations with several news crews on Jan. 20, 2020. The man also threw a reporter’s video camera to the ground, causing thousands of dollars of damage.
Reporters and photographers had gathered outside of a men’s apparel store to speak with owner Peter Carzis concerning allegations that he had engaged in lewd and inappropriate behavior in front of his shop.
Claudia Buccio, a multimedia journalist for Univision, posted on Instagram that she was capturing footage in front of the store for her piece and did not see Carzis approach her.
“He yanked my shoulder, pushed me and then he grabbed my camera and threw it to the sidewalk,” she wrote. “Thank God there were fellow journalists in the area who jumped out at my defense.”
Buccio wrote in a subsequent comment that several other news crews were in the area to report on the accusations against Carzis, but were in their vehicles and did not film the attack.
A crew from KUSI News, an independent station in San Diego, was among those who came to Buccio’s defense. KUSI News Director Steve Cohen told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that reporter Dan Plante stepped in to stop Carzis’ attack.
Plante recounted the incident in a live broadcast that evening.
“The first person he went after when he came out blazing was a young woman from Univision, and he pushed her up against the wall and he took her camera and he threw it in the street and broke it into a hundred pieces,” he said.
Carzis then turned on Plante.
A video taken by Plante on his cellphone shows Carzis attempting to hit him multiple times before rounding on KUSI cameraman Michael Saucedo, pushing him into a couple parking meters and pursuing him several yards down the sidewalk.
In the video, Plante can be heard telling Carzis that he’s “about to get arrested.” Carzis then turns again on Plante, attempting to both hit and kick him. A brief scuffle ensued as Plante attempted to keep Carzis at a distance, according to his accounting of the attack.
“When he was throwing punches at me, I was kind of laughing a little bit because I’m not afraid of a guy like that,” Plante said. “So what was going through my mind was, ‘Block the punches, block the kicks, get it all on video tape and expose this guy for who he is.’ And I believe that’s what happened.”
Carzis did land a blow against him, Plante said, resulting in a small cut on his nose from a piece of jewelry Carzis was wearing. Plante also dropped his phone in the altercation, but KUSI News Director Cohen told the Tracker it was not damaged.
Other journalists, including ABC 10News reporter Mimi Elkalla and photographer Virginia Creighton, witnessed the assaults but were not targeted by Carzis.
Plante called 911 and Carzis retreated to his store, locking the door behind him. Carzis was gone by the time police arrived, according to a press release from the La Mesa Police Department.
Police said that after canvassing the area, they located Carzis in nearby San Diego and arrested him on Jan. 21 on charges of misdemeanor battery and felony vandalism.
“Carzis is accused of battering multiple reporters and causing irreparable damage to a video camera reported to be worth approximately $7,000.00,” the press release states.
KUSI News Director Cohen told the Tracker that the broadcaster had not needed to press charges, but they expect Plante or Saucedo will need to provide testimony as the case against Carzis moves forward.
“It was just an absolutely crazy thing,” Plante said of the attack.
The U.S. Press Freedom Tracker catalogues press freedom violations in the United States. Email tips to [email protected].
