HTTP 200 OK
Access-Control-Allow-Methods: GET,OPTIONS,HEAD
Access-Control-Allow-Origin: *
Allow: GET, HEAD, OPTIONS
Content-Type: application/json
Link:
<http://pressfreedomtracker.us/api/edge/incidents/?format=api>; rel="first",
<http://pressfreedomtracker.us/api/edge/incidents/?cursor=cj0xJnA9MjAxOS0wNC0wMS00Njk3NGE4Yy0zYTdjLTExZWQtYTQ3Ny01NjYwZGNhNThlYzY%3D&format=api>; rel="prev",
<http://pressfreedomtracker.us/api/edge/incidents/?cursor=cD0yMDE5LTAyLTIyLTU0Mg%3D%3D&format=api>; rel="next"
Vary: Accept
[
{
"title": "Texas high school journalism adviser resigns; district implements prior review policies",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/texas-high-school-journalism-advisor-resigns-district-implements-prior-review-policies/",
"first_published_at": "2019-05-01T16:49:56.963315Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-02-29T18:59:52.865397Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-02-29T18:59:52.789404Z",
"date": "2019-04-01",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Katy",
"longitude": -95.8244,
"latitude": 29.78579,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"scd13\">The journalism adviser at a high school in Katy, Texas, has resigned after a prolonged conflict with school administration, which originated over how the yearbook should cover LGBTQ content. In the wake of this conflict, the principal also changed campus policy so that future issues of the yearbook will be subject to prior review.</p><p data-block-key=\"c1v2x\">The Seven Lakes High School teacher, Katie Moreno, declined to speak with the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker about the situation, citing the conditions of her employment contract with the Katy Independent School District. But she consulted with the legal team at the Student Press Law Center, and a staff attorney there, Sommer Ingram Dean, provided to the Tracker a 30-page document in which Moreno details her interactions with Seven Lakes principal Kerri Finnesand.</p><p data-block-key=\"bucoe\">“When a school district forces an award-winning journalism teacher to resign, you have to think there’s something more to the story than what school officials may be stating. Time and time again we see fearless journalism advisers teaching their students sound, responsible journalism, and winning awards for it, but still struggling to keep a job,” Dean said. “Every adviser that is bullied out of a job and every student that is pressured into silence is a threat to free speech. I hope Seven Lakes understands the gravity of this situation.”</p><p data-block-key=\"s16se\">Moreno, who has taught at Seven Lakes since January 2014, was awarded the Journalism Education Association’s “Rising Star” award in November 2018, according to an<a href=\"http://katytimes.com/education/article_b1f9a6ea-1e4b-11e9-8de0-97d16d333762.html\"> article</a> published by the Katy Times in January.</p><p data-block-key=\"4u1kj\">According to Moreno’s account, in November 2018 she brought a yearbook page for the Pride Club, the school’s group for LGBTQ students, to Finnesand for her review. The yearbook content had never been subject to prior review before, but Moreno showed it to Finnesand out of respect for a former administrator, whose child was featured on the page. Finnesand wrote in an email to Moreno that the administrator's child “will not be featured in the year book with the Pride Club” and ordered her to contact the parent of every student featured “about their child’s quote and the context of the club.” Finnesand did not respond to a request for comment.</p><p data-block-key=\"gyagn\">Moreno drafted a permission slip for parents to sign and let the adviser of the Pride Club know about it. The adviser protested, saying that no other clubs faced such a requirement, so it could be construed as discriminatory. When the adviser brought it up directly with Finnesand, the principal told Moreno she was being “insubordinate” by broaching the topic with the Pride Club adviser.</p><p data-block-key=\"374s1\">On Dec. 5, a yearbook student sent a private message on social media, writing that the principal wanted to change the publication layout for several groups, and have the parents of all Pride Club members sign a permission slip. The student lamented that “[a]ll the work we’ve done to build these clubs, all the memories, all the growth, will all be excluded from the yearbook if we don’t use our voice now in whatever ways possible.” Another student reposted the message, and Moreno brought the message to Finnesand’s attention, who viewed it as a “personal attack,” according to Moreno’s documentation.</p><p data-block-key=\"z4y1u\">The next afternoon, Finnesand came into Moreno’s classroom and confronted her within earshot of her students. “She said I’m not doing my job, and that I clearly can’t control my kids. And I ‘let’ them go to social media to slander her. And because of that I don’t need to be the yearbook adviser here,” Moreno wrote.</p><p data-block-key=\"0mxkl\">A meeting between Finnesand and Moreno’s journalism students took place on Dec. 7, where they agreed on a plan on how to cover non-curriculum clubs in the yearbook going forward.</p><p data-block-key=\"g003r\">After the students left that meeting, Finnesand spoke with Moreno again where she expressed that she never has problems dealing with leaders of other organizations. Moreno, in her document, wrote her interactions with Finnesand left her feeling belittled: “[d]ue to the nature of student publications, there will be times she needs to have a conversation with the adviser and with the editors. Every single time I have contacted her with a question or an update, I am met with animosity, condescension, and judgement. This is an unfair comparison, as issues regarding censorship do not arise from service organizations or athletics.”</p><p data-block-key=\"noq9q\">The print edition of the school’s newspaper, The Torch, has always operated under prior review. Moreno’s students dropped off a proof of the December issue for review by Finnesand on Dec. 3, and it was returned to Moreno without any comments. The issue’s cover included an edited image of a girl surrounded by a cloud of smoke, accompanying an article about vaping titled “A Fatal Fad.” The photograph was taken using dry ice. The cover was included in the approved proof binder, but after the issue was distributed, Moreno was given a performance review memorandum to sign for the image appearing on the cover.</p><p data-block-key=\"e1o5v\">Following a series of interactions with Finnesand, Moreno sent a grievance letter to Jeff Stocks, assistant superintendent of the Katy ISD, in which she outlined the communication difficulties she was having with Finnesand. At a meeting with Stocks and Finnesand on Jan. 8, 2019, Moreno was giving a document that stated that “campus administration will approve all pages of the SLHS yearbook,” a departure from the previous policy that did not require prior review. At the conclusion of that meeting, Finnesand informed Moreno that she would not be the yearbook or newspaper sponsor next school year, according to Moreno’s account.</p><p data-block-key=\"nozzi\">According to Moreno’s account, after a series of meetings with a school district Human Resources representative where the future of Moreno’s teaching contract was called into question, she opted to resign on April 1, 2019.</p><p data-block-key=\"sfdhz\">Moreno will teach through the end of the school year, and in her resignation cited her intention to find a teaching position in another school district, Ingram Dean at the SPLC told the Tracker.</p><p data-block-key=\"kr016\">Justin Graham, the general counsel for Katy ISD, told the Tracker in an email that Moreno resigned “unilaterally and voluntarily” from her job at Seven Lakes.</p><p data-block-key=\"nnxcu\"><i>Editor's Note: A previous version of this article incorrectly identified Jeff Stocks as superintendent of Katy Independent School District. Stocks is assistant superintendent.</i></p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/katy_teacher_students.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"aeauh\">Journalism adviser Katie Moreno, left, works with Seven Lakes High School students in Katy, Texas. In April 2019, Moreno resigned from her position following a series of disagreements with school administration about content.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Texas",
"abbreviation": "TX"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [
"Katy Times"
],
"tags": [
"LGBTQ+ rights",
"student journalism"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Other Incident"
],
"targeted_journalists": [],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "Judge limits media access to evidence in Minnesota police shooting trial",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-limits-media-access-evidence-minnesota-police-shooting-trial/",
"first_published_at": "2019-04-04T20:20:59.122542Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-01-11T18:02:53.184250Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-01-11T18:02:53.101249Z",
"date": "2019-03-29",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Minneapolis",
"longitude": -93.26384,
"latitude": 44.97997,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"2e8m7\">The judge presiding over the murder trial of former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor ruled on March 29, 2019, that media and members of the public will be restricted from viewing “graphic evidence”—including body cam footage and photographs from the crime scene and medical examiner’s office—in the case that will be displayed for the jury.</p><p data-block-key=\"efjq5\">At a final pretrial hearing, Hennepin County District Judge Kathryn L. Quaintance said she was blocking this evidence from being seen by anyone aside from the jury and attorneys in the case because “there’s privacy interest involved,”<a href=\"http://www.startribune.com/attorneys-judge-to-address-final-details-in-upcoming-noor-trial/507825992/\"> according</a> to the Minneapolis Star-Tribune. She called airing this evidence publicly “inflammatory, potentially” as it “shows the deceased in extremely compromising situations.”</p><p data-block-key=\"8emnn\">Noor is accused of fatally shooting Justine Ruszczyk Damond, an Australian woman who had called police to alert them to a possible assault taking place in the alleyway behind her home. Noor allegedly shot and killed her when she approached his police cruiser. Jury selection in the case began on April 1.</p><p data-block-key=\"i9og4\">A coalition of media representatives including the Minneapolis Star-Tribune and Minnesota Public Radio filed a <a href=\"http://mncourts.gov/mncourtsgov/media/High-Profile-Cases/27-CR-18-6859/NoticeofMotionandMotion040219.pdf\">motion</a> on April 2 objecting to Quaintance’s ruling barring media from viewing evidence, arguing it amounts to a unconstitutional “de facto closure of the courtroom.”</p><p data-block-key=\"v81nr\">“Excluding the press and public from viewing evidence presented to the jury and other trial participants violates the Constitutional and common law rights of press and public access to criminal proceedings,” wrote Leita Walker, an attorney for the media coalition, in a <a href=\"http://mncourts.gov/mncourtsgov/media/High-Profile-Cases/27-CR-18-6859/MemoranduminSupportofMotion040219.pdf\">memorandum</a> supporting the motion.</p><p data-block-key=\"87fgd\">As of publication, the motion had not been scheduled for a hearing. Jury selection in the case is ongoing.</p><p data-block-key=\"15238\">Courts have upheld the notion that media outlets and the public have a right to “contemporaneous access” to evidence during a trial, Walker argued, citing the Second Circuit case ABC v. Stewart, where the court found “[t]he ability to see and to hear a proceeding as it unfolds is a vital component of the First Amendment right of access—not . . . an incremental benefit.” Additionally, Quaintance’s argument is invalid, Walker wrote, as the state of Minnesota “does not recognize a posthumous right to privacy.”</p><p data-block-key=\"w6w6m\">The judge’s decision to limit access to evidence “clearly crossed a constitutional boundary,” Mark Anfinson, an attorney for the Minnesota Newspaper Association, told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker.</p><p data-block-key=\"xunrv\">In an <a href=\"http://mncourts.gov/mncourtsgov/media/High-Profile-Cases/27-CR-18-6859/OrderonConductatTrial032719.pdf\">order</a> issued on March 27, Quaintance wrote that to preserve “order and decorum” in the courtroom, space devoted to the media will be limited to eight seats, of which four will be available to local media outlets and four to national and international outlets. Four seats each will be reserved for the family members of the victim and defendant, one for a sketch artists, which leaves only 11 seats for the public, <a href=\"http://www.mnspj.org/2019/03/29/mnspj-opposes-hennepin-county-courts-severe-restrictions-on-noor-shooting-trial-coverage/\">according</a> to Joe Spear, the president of the Minnesota Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists. The Minneapolis Star-Tribune <a href=\"http://www.startribune.com/judge-restricts-media-public-s-access-to-noor-murder-trial/507810372/\">noted</a> that other courtrooms in the building contain double the amount of seating.</p><p data-block-key=\"i70np\">The judge’s initial <a href=\"http://mncourts.gov/mncourtsgov/media/High-Profile-Cases/27-CR-18-6859/OrderonConductatTrial032719.pdf\">order</a> stated that overflow seating will be available in another courtroom, where an audio feed of the proceedings will be played. But after media outcry, Quaintance issued an amended <a href=\"http://mncourts.gov/mncourtsgov/media/High-Profile-Cases/27-CR-18-6859/AmendedOrderonConductatTrial032819.pdf\">order</a> the next day stating that a video feed would be available in that overflow courtroom as well.</p><p data-block-key=\"bjb5a\">Walker, the attorney for the media coalition, in a March 29 letter to Judge Ivy Bernhardson, the Chief Judge of Minnesota’s Fourth Judicial District, asked that the trial be moved to a larger courtroom, or a second overflow room be reserved for media. “The Coalition is dismayed that, on the eve of trial, uncertainties remain about whether the press and public will be able to adequately monitor one of the highest profile trials the State of Minnesota has ever seen,” Walker wrote. In response, Judges Bernhardson and Quaintance on April 1 added seven more media seats to the existing courtroom, <a href=\"http://www.startribune.com/after-backlash-seven-new-seats-added-for-media-at-noor-trial/507977122/\">according</a> to the Star Tribune.</p><p data-block-key=\"hlmkw\">Quaintance’s order also banned all electronic or recording devices, including cellphones, tablets, and laptops, from the entire floor of the courthouse where the trial was taking place.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/RTS2FW5L.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"imo94\">Mohamed Noor, far right, enters the courthouse with his attorneys ahead of the murder trial against the former Minneapolis, Minnesota, police officer, charged in the 2017 fatal shooting of Justine Ruszczyk Damond.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Minnesota",
"abbreviation": "MN"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [
"Media",
"Minnesota Public Radio",
"Minnesota Star Tribune"
],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [
"Judiciary: District Court"
],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Denial of Access"
],
"targeted_journalists": [],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": [
"Change in policy or practice",
"Other"
]
},
{
"title": "Texas law enforcement seizes gear from TV crew",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/texas-law-enforcement-seizes-gear-from-tv-crew/",
"first_published_at": "2025-02-26T17:10:13.504978Z",
"last_published_at": "2025-03-03T16:02:09.615419Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2025-03-03T16:02:09.394364Z",
"date": "2019-03-28",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Austin",
"longitude": -97.74306,
"latitude": 30.26715,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"o9m89\">Law enforcement officials in Austin, Texas, briefly seized equipment belonging to the crew of reality TV show “Live PD” after the crew filmed the death of a man in custody on March 28, 2019, according to news reports and court documents reviewed by the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker.</p><p data-block-key=\"cm35d\">“Live PD” parent company Big Fish Entertainment <a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/59770975/big-fish-entertainment-llc-v-williamson-county-sheriffs-office/\">sued</a> the City of Austin, Williamson County and 11 police officers on March 26, 2021, alleging violations of the First, Fourth and 14th amendments and the Privacy Protection Act in connection with the incident.</p><p data-block-key=\"d95va\">The reality show followed the activities of police officers across the U.S., with camera crews and producers embedded with patrols and riding along in police vehicles.</p><p data-block-key=\"fetu7\">On that day in 2019, producers and camera operators Colin Mika and Jeff Moriarty, along with associate producer Ruby Garson Tarzian, were riding in two separate squad cars — with GoPro cameras mounted on the windshields of each — when the Williamson County sheriff’s deputies began chasing Javier Ambler II after he allegedly failed to dim his headlights.</p><p data-block-key=\"51hg6\">After more than 20 minutes, Ambler’s car became disabled and officers tried to handcuff him, shocking him with Tasers four times. Mika and Moriarty got out of the squad cars and filmed the encounter with handheld cameras.</p><p data-block-key=\"3j10f\">Ambler, who was Black, repeatedly told officers he had congestive heart failure and could not breathe. He eventually became unconscious and was pronounced dead about an hour later.</p><p data-block-key=\"8cbbi\">In an <a href=\"https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1128115/gov.uscourts.txwd.1128115.8.0.pdf\">amended complaint</a> filed on April 23, 2021, the production company said that the crew stopped filming when Ambler became nonresponsive. Soon after, it added, officers from the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office and the Austin Police Department “took the extraordinary step of jointly seizing the production crew’s cameras and footage of the incident that the crew had left in WCSO squad cars.”</p><p data-block-key=\"bj1b3\">Mika kept his handheld camera with him, according to the complaint, but left his GoPro and other equipment in one of the sheriff’s vehicles. Moriarty’s handheld camera, GoPro and other equipment <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/texas-law-enforcement-seizes-cameras-equipment-from-tv-crew\">were also seized</a>, along with Tarzian’s personal belongings.</p><p data-block-key=\"5obkv\">The seizure took place in the absence of “a warrant, a subpoena, or even probable cause to believe that any of the Live PD crew had committed or was committing a criminal offense,” according to the complaint.</p><p data-block-key=\"bjanr\">The production company said that officers prevented the crew from retrieving their cameras from the squad cars because they considered the footage “to be evidence secured in the police custody.”</p><p data-block-key=\"64iu0\">After more than an hour, the crew was allowed to recover their equipment from the squad cars, and then they left the scene.</p><p data-block-key=\"a2kt2\">The next day, the crew sent the recordings to Big Fish’s editorial office in New York, which reviewed the footage and decided not to air it. The company noted in the complaint that it had anticipated that Texas officials would issue a court order for the video as part of a probe into Ambler’s death — and that they were prepared to provide it — but no one ever asked for it.</p><p data-block-key=\"48u1f\">The complaint said the footage was destroyed after 30 days in accordance with a clause in the show’s contract with Williamson County, <a href=\"https://www.statesman.com/story/news/local/2024/08/14/who-responsible-for-destruction-video-in-ambler-death-javier-chody-nassour-trial-tampering-live-pd/74771979007/\">reportedly added after Ambler’s death</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"fonbn\">In June 2020, the Austin American-Statesman and TV station KVUE published an <a href=\"https://www.statesman.com/story/lifestyle/public-safety/2020/06/08/austin-area-police-chase-ends-in-death-as-lsquolive-pdrsquo-cameras-roll/43273631/\">investigation</a> into Ambler’s death that made public the police body camera footage and other documents. That report came in the wake of widespread protests after the May 2020 killing in police custody of another Black man, George Floyd, in Minneapolis.</p><p data-block-key=\"4q1mr\">Amid renewed scrutiny of the Ambler case, “Live PD” was accused by Texas officials of failing to cooperate with an official probe into the incident, including refusing to turn over the footage.</p><p data-block-key=\"fr0ag\">In the suit, Big Fish alleged that investigators made those allegations to cover up the fact that they failed to undertake a meaningful investigation into Ambler’s killing until June 2020. It also noted that the entire incident was captured on the officers’ body cameras and dashcams, duplicating the “Live PD” footage.</p><p data-block-key=\"bb5u\">The case was dismissed on Aug. 22, 2023, after the parties agreed in June 2021 to stay and abate the proceedings in light of “other pending proceedings related to the same subject matter.”</p><p data-block-key=\"8no8b\">It was not immediately clear what proceedings they were referring to. However, two former Williamson County officials <a href=\"https://www.statesman.com/story/news/local/2024/08/14/who-responsible-for-destruction-video-in-ambler-death-javier-chody-nassour-trial-tampering-live-pd/74771979007/\">went on trial</a> in August 2024 on charges of evidence tampering in the Ambler case; they were accused of taking steps to ensure that the “Live PD” footage was destroyed. The case was <a href=\"https://www.kxan.com/news/local/williamson-county/judge-grants-stay-in-tampering-case-against-former-sheriff-robert-chody-prosecutor/\">stayed</a> for an indefinite period later that month.</p><p data-block-key=\"8qkc8\">Williamson County’s Public Affairs Department declined to comment. The Austin Police Department, in an emailed statement, noted: “Litigation was dismissed without any findings or wrongdoing against the City or any settlement by the City.”</p><p data-block-key=\"fr91k\">Big Fish and its attorneys Elizabeth McNamara and David Gonzalez did not respond to emailed requests for comment.</p><p data-block-key=\"aud2l\"><i>Editor’s Note: This article has been updated to include responses from Williamson County and the Austin Police Department.</i></p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screenshot_2025-02-26_at_11.43.00.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"z36gw\">A portion of a complaint filed on March 26, 2021, by Big Fish Entertainment over the seizure of camera equipment and footage from the crew of its “Live PD” TV series after a police-related death in Austin, Texas, two years earlier.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": "1:21-cv-00275",
"case_type": "CIVIL",
"status_of_seized_equipment": "returned in full",
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [
{
"quantity": 1,
"equipment": "camera"
},
{
"quantity": 1,
"equipment": "camera equipment"
}
],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Texas",
"abbreviation": "TX"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [
"dismissed"
],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Equipment Search or Seizure"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Colin Mika (Big Fish Entertainment)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": null,
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "Texas law enforcement seizes cameras, equipment from TV crew",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/texas-law-enforcement-seizes-cameras-equipment-from-tv-crew/",
"first_published_at": "2025-02-26T17:12:34.188833Z",
"last_published_at": "2025-04-03T23:52:16.041988Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2025-04-03T23:52:15.938558Z",
"date": "2019-03-28",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Austin",
"longitude": -97.74306,
"latitude": 30.26715,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"xprkl\">Law enforcement officials in Austin, Texas, briefly seized equipment belonging to the crew of reality TV show “Live PD” after the crew filmed the death of a man in custody on March 28, 2019, according to news reports and court documents reviewed by the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker.</p><p data-block-key=\"3apao\">“Live PD” parent company Big Fish Entertainment <a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/59770975/big-fish-entertainment-llc-v-williamson-county-sheriffs-office/\">sued</a> the city of Austin, Williamson County and 11 police officers on March 26, 2021, alleging violations of the First, Fourth and 14th amendments and the Privacy Protection Act in connection with the incident.</p><p data-block-key=\"4lagf\">The reality show followed the activities of police officers across the U.S., with camera crews and producers embedded with patrols and riding along in police vehicles.</p><p data-block-key=\"afmfm\">On that day in 2019, producers and camera operators Jeff Moriarty and Colin Mika, along with associate producer Ruby Garson Tarzian, were riding in two separate squad cars — with GoPro cameras mounted on the windshields of each — when the Williamson County sheriff’s deputies began chasing Javier Ambler II after he allegedly failed to dim his headlights.</p><p data-block-key=\"3832u\">After more than 20 minutes, Ambler’s car became disabled and officers tried to handcuff him, shocking him with Tasers four times. Mika and Moriarty got out of the squad cars and filmed the encounter with handheld cameras.</p><p data-block-key=\"9i165\">Ambler, who was Black, repeatedly told officers he had congestive heart failure and could not breathe. He eventually became unconscious and was pronounced dead about an hour later.</p><p data-block-key=\"6l9k8\">In an <a href=\"https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.txwd.1128115/gov.uscourts.txwd.1128115.8.0.pdf\">amended complaint</a> filed on April 23, 2021, the production company said that the crew stopped filming when Ambler became nonresponsive. Soon after, it added, officers from the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office and the Austin Police Department “took the extraordinary step of jointly seizing the production crew’s cameras and footage of the incident that the crew had left in WCSO squad cars.”</p><p data-block-key=\"17un8\">Moriarty placed his handheld camera along with his other equipment in a sheriff’s vehicle after officers began their investigation, according to the complaint, and they were seized along with his GoPro. Mika’s GoPro and camera equipment <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/texas-law-enforcement-seizes-gear-from-tv-crew\">were also seized</a>, along with Tarzian’s personal belongings.</p><p data-block-key=\"9fo34\">The seizure took place in the absence of “a warrant, a subpoena, or even probable cause to believe that any of the Live PD crew had committed or was committing a criminal offense,” according to the complaint.</p><p data-block-key=\"76vaq\">The production company said that officers prevented the crew from retrieving their cameras from the squad cars because they considered the footage “to be evidence secured in the police custody.”</p><p data-block-key=\"p7nm\">After more than an hour, the crew was allowed to recover their equipment from the squad cars, and then they left the scene.</p><p data-block-key=\"5th93\">The next day, the crew sent the recordings to Big Fish’s editorial office in New York, which reviewed the footage and decided not to air it. The company noted in the complaint that it had anticipated that Texas officials would issue a court order for the video as part of a probe into Ambler’s death — and that they were prepared to provide it — but no one ever asked for it.</p><p data-block-key=\"duj92\">The complaint said the footage was destroyed after 30 days in accordance with a clause in the show’s contract with Williamson County, <a href=\"https://www.statesman.com/story/news/local/2024/08/14/who-responsible-for-destruction-video-in-ambler-death-javier-chody-nassour-trial-tampering-live-pd/74771979007/\">reportedly added after Ambler’s death</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"4225n\">In June 2020, the Austin American-Statesman and TV station KVUE published an <a href=\"https://www.statesman.com/story/lifestyle/public-safety/2020/06/08/austin-area-police-chase-ends-in-death-as-lsquolive-pdrsquo-cameras-roll/43273631/\">investigation</a> into Ambler’s death that made public the police body camera footage and other documents. That report came in the wake of widespread protests after the May 2020 killing in police custody of another Black man, George Floyd, in Minneapolis.</p><p data-block-key=\"ef084\">Amid renewed scrutiny of the Ambler case, “Live PD” was accused by Texas officials of failing to cooperate with an official probe into the incident, including refusing to turn over the footage.</p><p data-block-key=\"12jim\">In the suit, Big Fish alleged that investigators made those allegations to cover up the fact that they failed to undertake a meaningful investigation into Ambler’s killing until June 2020. It also noted that the entire incident was captured on the officers’ body cameras and dashcams, duplicating the “Live PD” footage.</p><p data-block-key=\"atang\">The case was dismissed on Aug. 22, 2023, after the parties agreed in June 2021 to stay and abate the proceedings in light of “other pending proceedings related to the same subject matter.”</p><p data-block-key=\"6q638\">It was not immediately clear what proceedings they were referring to. However, two former Williamson County officials <a href=\"https://www.statesman.com/story/news/local/2024/08/14/who-responsible-for-destruction-video-in-ambler-death-javier-chody-nassour-trial-tampering-live-pd/74771979007/\">went on trial</a> in August 2024 on charges of evidence tampering in the Ambler case; they were accused of taking steps to ensure that the “Live PD” footage was destroyed. The case was <a href=\"https://www.kxan.com/news/local/williamson-county/judge-grants-stay-in-tampering-case-against-former-sheriff-robert-chody-prosecutor/\">stayed</a> for an indefinite period later that month.</p><p data-block-key=\"doijb\">Williamson County’s Public Affairs Department declined to comment. The Austin Police Department, in an emailed statement, noted: “Litigation was dismissed without any findings or wrongdoing against the City or any settlement by the City.”</p><p data-block-key=\"1agrp\">Big Fish and its attorneys Elizabeth McNamara and David Gonzalez did not respond to emailed requests for comment.</p><p data-block-key=\"e0v6p\"><i>Editor’s Note: This article has been updated to include responses from Williamson County and the Austin Police Department.</i></p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screenshot_2025-02-26_at_11.43.00.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"qlwb4\">A portion of a complaint filed on March 26, 2021, by Big Fish Entertainment over the seizure of camera equipment and footage from the crew of its “Live PD” TV series after a police-related death in Austin, Texas, two years earlier.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": "1:21-cv-00275",
"case_type": "CIVIL",
"status_of_seized_equipment": "returned in full",
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [
{
"quantity": 2,
"equipment": "camera"
},
{
"quantity": 1,
"equipment": "camera equipment"
}
],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Texas",
"abbreviation": "TX"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [
"dismissed"
],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Equipment Search or Seizure"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Jeff Moriarty (Big Fish Entertainment)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": null,
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "New York County Supreme Court judge quashes subpoena for HBO documentary outtakes",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/new-york-county-supreme-court-judge-quashes-subpoena-hbo-documentary-outtakes/",
"first_published_at": "2019-06-07T20:30:15.035851Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-04-03T15:44:24.443814Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-04-03T15:44:24.344123Z",
"date": "2019-03-27",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "New York",
"longitude": -74.00597,
"latitude": 40.71427,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"u4qjf\">New York County Supreme Court Judge Carol Edmead quashed a subpoena for outtakes from the HBO documentary “Rock and a Hard Place” on June 5, 2019, citing New York’s shield law.</p><p data-block-key=\"qior9\">Christy Laster, a former correctional officer who appeared in the documentary, stands charged of bribery, grand theft and extortion, but alleged the footage she sought through the subpoena would exonerate her, <a href=\"http://nycourts.gov/reporter/3dseries/2019/2019_29164.htm\">according to the ruling</a>. Laster argued that because Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson appeared in and produced the documentary, it was rendered a “celebrity reality TV show” and therefore would not be protected under the statute.</p><p data-block-key=\"9ib7p\">Edmead dismissed this categorization, <a href=\"http://nycourts.gov/reporter/3dseries/2019/2019_29164.htm\">writing in her decision</a> that Laster “cites no authority for the notion that the mere involvement of a celebrity in a project renders it somehow incapable of being classified as a documentary, or that a celebrity known for other endeavors cannot be deemed a ‘journalist’ under the [shield law].”</p><p data-block-key=\"b0uju\">In addition to his credit as an executive producer for “Rock and a Hard Place,” Johnson was the executive producer of the episode “Stand Your Ground” in the “Finding Justice” series and of the feature documentary “Racing Dreams.”</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/RTX5GT5W.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"8hpxs\">The New York County Supreme Court ruled that the state’s shield law applies to Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson in his role producing the 2017 documentary film, “Rock and a Hard Place.”</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": "journalist communications or work product",
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "New York",
"abbreviation": "NY"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Dwayne \"The Rock\" Johnson (HBO)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [
"quashed"
],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Reporter assaulted by heavyweight boxer during on-camera interview",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/reporter-assaulted-heavyweight-boxer-during-camera-interview/",
"first_published_at": "2019-07-25T20:42:37.653895Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-01-17T21:36:54.506959Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-01-17T21:36:54.423054Z",
"date": "2019-03-23",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Costa Mesa",
"longitude": -117.91867,
"latitude": 33.64113,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"cgcaw\">A heavyweight boxer forced a kiss on a reporter during an on-camera interview following a match in Costa Mesa, California, on March 23, 2019.</p><p data-block-key=\"hp50s\">Jennifer Ravalo, a Vegas Sports Daily contributor and web host who uses the byline <a href=\"http://vegassportsdaily.com/author/jenny/\">Jennifer SuShe</a>, was conducting a video interview following Bulgarian Kubrat Pulev’s knockout victory when he grabbed her face, reached around her back and kissed her on the lips.</p><p data-block-key=\"ob93t\">In the <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WE05akv_k08\">video of the incident</a>, Ravalo initially appears to laugh it off, saying, “All right, thank you,” as Pulev walks away. Ravalo later lodged a complaint with the California State Athletic Commission asserting that the kiss was without her consent and unwelcome. Ravalo also said Pulev sexually harassed her a second time, moments after the interview.</p><p data-block-key=\"myfsq\">“I was immediately shocked and embarrassed, and didn’t know how to respond,” Ravalo said while reading from a prepared statement at a <a href=\"https://www.facebook.com/gloriaallred/videos/10157199305955879/\">press conference</a> following the incident. “Next, I walked to the table to put my items in my backpack. He grabbed both of my buttocks and squeezed with both of his hands. Then he walked away without saying anything to me and laughed.”</p><p data-block-key=\"sfyr4\">The commission suspended Pulev’s boxing license for six months in May, the New York Daily News <a href=\"https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/ny-boxer-can-return-to-ring-after-kissing-reporter-without-consent-20190722-4dyov36lp5gfpn7chnamzrwagy-story.html\">reported</a>, citing him for violating rules prohibiting conduct considered a “discredit to boxing.” Pulev was also fined $2,500 and ordered to attended a sexual harassment awareness course.</p><p data-block-key=\"svvv7\">On July 22, the commission voted unanimously to lift the suspension on Pulev with the caveat that another violation could result in a lifetime suspension.</p><p data-block-key=\"axx8u\">“It’s disappointing he didn’t do the full six months,” Ravalo said. “I don’t know if he’s really sorry. I won’t know until I see how he acts.”</p><p data-block-key=\"0eutb\">Attorney Gloria Allred, who is representing Ravalo, has also spoken out against comments made by Pulev’s promoter, Bob Arum, Reuters <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-boxing-pulev/california-boxing-license-returned-to-bulgarian-athlete-who-forcibly-kissed-reporter-idUSKCN1UI03U\">reported</a>. In an <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhaOuVwIQyg&feature=youtu.be\">interview on iFL TV</a> posted to YouTube on June 15, Arum claimed that Ravalo had been “fooling around” with Pulev ahead of the fight in March and that Pulev’s suspension was “totally crazy” as he “did nothing wrong.”</p><p data-block-key=\"z02xn\">Allred called the statement “blatantly false,” pointing to the fact that both Pulev and Ravalo testified before the commission that they first met at the weigh-in the day before the fight, The Washington Post <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/07/23/boxer-who-kissed-female-reporter-ring-can-fight-again-says-it-was-my-mistake/?utm_term=.b48648d763e1\">reported</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"lrl3u\">Ravalo <a href=\"https://www.kpbs.org/news/2019/jul/23/boxing-license-reinstated-for-fighter-who-forced/\">told KPBS</a> that the incident and subsequent fallout has negatively impacted her career. Arum and his promotion company, which represents almost 100 boxers, will not allow her to cover their events and some boxers have been standoffish about providing interviews, she said.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/RTX3FP0J.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"z2mza\">The California State Athletic Commission recently reinstated the boxing license of Kubrat Pulev, seen here at a 2017 press conference, following his suspension for forcibly kissing and groping a reporter.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": "public figure",
"was_journalist_targeted": "yes",
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"sexual assault"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Assault"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Jennifer Ravalo (Vegas Sports Daily)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": null,
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "Pennsylvania borough settles lawsuit after punitively withdrawing advertising from local newspaper",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-borough-settles-lawsuit-after-punitively-withdrawing-advertising-local-newspaper/",
"first_published_at": "2019-04-05T17:59:11.309012Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-01-16T19:14:59.149033Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-01-16T19:14:59.053255Z",
"date": "2019-03-19",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Borough of Middletown",
"longitude": null,
"latitude": null,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"poel6\">On March 19, 2019, the Borough of Middletown in Pennsylvania agreed to a settlement on a lawsuit filed by the Press & Journal, a local weekly. The newspaper sued after the mayor and borough council sent an official policy letter withdrawing advertising dollars from the Press & Journal in retaliation for the paper’s reporting and editorializing.</p><p data-block-key=\"osvlk\">Joseph Sukle, publisher and vice president of the Press & Journal, told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that there had been contentions with the borough over the last year or so.</p><p data-block-key=\"c8oij\">“I guess they didn’t like what we were reporting or the editorial viewpoints that we expressed, and then they just cut off all communications and not talking to us or our reporters, not commenting,” Sukle said.</p><p data-block-key=\"7znvu\">Sukle said he noticed that the borough stopped publishing public notices in the newspaper in June 2018. When he reached out to the borough to see if there was a problem, he was told he would shortly receive an official communication.</p><p data-block-key=\"5tduh\">Mayor James Curry III and six out of seven of the Middletown Borough Council members sent Sukle a <a href=\"http://cdn4.creativecirclemedia.com/pressandjournal/original/20190326-161915-Ltr_MtownBC_7_17_2018.jpg\">signed policy letter</a> the next month. The letter claimed that the newspaper’s reporting and editorials had been “detrimental to the efforts and initiatives of the Borough” and that it has contained “disheartening and demoralizing instances of distasteful sensationalism, misrepresentation of information and statements, unfounded speculation, questionable sourcing and observable bias.”</p><p data-block-key=\"qza2i\">The letter ended: “Should the Press and Journal demonstrate reliability to professionally and responsibly report on the actions and statements of Borough Council and Management, as well [sic] critiquing us from a founded and balanced position, we will be happy to patron your newspaper again.”</p><p data-block-key=\"taiwe\">In an <a href=\"http://pressandjournal.com/stories/we-are-not-the-enemy-editorial,55807\">editorial following the settlement</a>, the Press & Journal wrote that the letter took no pains to hide the meaning of the advertising ban: “In short, the letter was evidence of an unapologetic retaliation aimed at speech protected by the First Amendment.”</p><p data-block-key=\"o2td7\">In an effort to resolve the issue out of court, Aaron Martin, the newspaper’s attorney, appeared at a Sept. 18 borough council meeting to read a <a href=\"http://www.pressandjournal.com/stories/press-journal-lawyers-letter-to-council-we-implore-you-to-correct-the-unconstitutional,41133?\">letter</a> requesting a retraction of the policy letter. It argued that the council’s withdrawal of the borough’s advertising after a decades-long business relationship was a First Amendment violation.</p><p data-block-key=\"d0knq\">“This attempted punishment of a member of the free press—requiring a kind of probationary penitence prior to restoration—is a naked attempt to coerce favorable press coverage,” the letter <a href=\"http://www.pressandjournal.com/stories/press-journal-lawyers-letter-to-council-we-implore-you-to-correct-the-unconstitutional,41133?\">reads</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"pgkai\">The Press & Journal provided copies of the letter to each council member and Mayor Curry.</p><p data-block-key=\"bhqjh\">“While our attorney was standing there, and just about the time he was finished reading it,” Sukle said, “the mayor actually takes the letter, takes it in his hands, rips it apart, and tosses it on the desk in full view of everybody: fellow councilors, our attorney. It was just an incredible action by an elected official.”</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"kfjdc\"></p><hr/><p data-block-key=\"4f73v\"><br/></p></div>\n<div class=\"block-image\">\n\n\n<img src=\"https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Mayor_Curry_tears_letter_in_half2x.width-828.png\" width=\"828\" height=\"184\" alt=\"Photo collage\">\n</div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"5y2jp\">In this photo collage from a recording, Borough of Middletown Mayor James Curry III, back left, rips a letter from the Press & Journal during the Sept. 18, 2018, borough council meeting. The recording can be found at: <a href=\"https://middletownborough.com/event/borough-council-meeting-16/\">https://middletownborough.com/event/borough-council-meeting-16/</a></p><hr/><p data-block-key=\"uwxxv\"></p></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"3f492\">The paper asked that the council respond within seven days to its request in an effort to resolve the dispute out of court. Sukle told the Tracker that, in the end, they waited more than two weeks.</p><p data-block-key=\"g9mnx\">On Oct. 23, 2018, the law firm of Mette, Evans & Woodside filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the borough on the newspaper’s behalf, asserting violations of the Press & Journal’s rights to free speech and free press under the First Amendment.</p><p data-block-key=\"esq6v\">Within days, Council President Angela Lloyd <a href=\"https://middletownborough.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/2018.10.26-Press-Release.pdf\">issued a press release</a> stating, “The global services offered by the Press and Journal do not meet the Borough’s needs.” She also charged that the suit had “no merit in fact or law.”</p><p data-block-key=\"gani0\">On Nov. 14, the borough <a href=\"https://dockets.justia.com/docket/pennsylvania/pamdce/1:2018cv02064/118460\">attempted</a> to have the suit dismissed. However, U.S. District Court Judge Christopher Conner ruled against the borough and denied its request for dismissal on Dec. 13, stating that while no formal contract existed between the borough and the Press & Journal, the borough had placed more than 200 notices over the previous 10 years, establishing a reasonable expectation of future business.</p><p data-block-key=\"84b0z\">Though government bodies are required to publish certain public notices in publications available to the populations they serve, there are no federally mandated guidelines. In order to not violate the first amendment rights of publications, government entities cannot take into account the content or viewpoint of the news service as a criteria for placing public notices.</p><p data-block-key=\"vmild\">“Judge Conner’s decision will likely provide support to other media outlets facing retaliatory action by government for their reporting and editorializing,” Martin, the newspaper’s attorney, said in the Press & Journal’s editorial.</p><p data-block-key=\"6m9tc\">Under the terms of the settlement reached in March, the borough is required to spell out its criteria for placing advertisements on bases that are “content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral consistent with the First Amendment of the United States Constitution.” Of the six council members who signed the official letter to the Press & Journal, five remain on the council that established these criteria through a resolution.</p><p data-block-key=\"rm138\">Sukle, however, told the Tracker that the criteria are written in a way that excludes the Press & Journal because it is a weekly publication. Further, Sukle said, the mayor has continued to restrict the newspaper’s access, most significantly to the police department.</p><p data-block-key=\"96bxb\">“It’s gone so far that our staff—almost all of our staff—is blocked from the mayor’s Facebook pages, so we can’t access those,” Sukle said.</p><p data-block-key=\"f0o5r\">The newspaper did not ask for damages in the suit, though the settlement did require that Middletown Borough pay $22,000 to the Press & Journal’s law firm for legal costs.</p><p data-block-key=\"dvbbk\">In the editorial discussing the settlement, the Press & Journal wrote that it is undeterred by the borough council and mayor’s attempts to sway the newspaper’s reporting or editorializing: “We are not the borough council’s enemy. And we are not its PR firm.”</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Middletown_notice.9dc2df8b.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"vg3op\">A signed letter from Borough of Middletown, Pennsylvania, council members and mayor explicitly links withdrawal of the borough's advertising dollars to what it considers "detrimental" editorial content.<br/></p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Pennsylvania",
"abbreviation": "PA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [
"[Middletown] Press & Journal"
],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Other Incident"
],
"targeted_journalists": [],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "Department of State bars press pool from briefing call, allowing only “faith-based media”",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/department-state-bars-press-pool-briefing-call-allowing-only-faith-based-media/",
"first_published_at": "2019-03-25T17:06:27.177663Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-12-21T17:07:01.529386Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-12-21T17:07:01.452197Z",
"date": "2019-03-18",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Washington",
"longitude": -77.03637,
"latitude": 38.89511,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"ghgf4\">The State Department barred the department’s press corps from a briefing call with Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on March 18, 2019, stating that only “faith-based media” were permitted to participate. The department also took the unusual step of refusing to release a full transcript or a list of attendees.</p><p data-block-key=\"r9ygi\">The phone briefing was to discuss “international religious freedom” ahead of the secretary’s five-day trip to Beirut, Jerusalem, and Kuwait City. CNN <a href=\"https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/18/politics/state-department-faith-outlets-briefing/index.html\">reported</a> that one member of the department’s press corps was invited, but was un-invited after RSVPing. CNN also attempted to RSVP to the call, but received no reply from the department.</p><p data-block-key=\"38bqn\">Despite repeated inquiries and complaints from members of the press corps, The State Department announced that it would not provide a transcript of the call, a list of the faith-based media outlets allowed to participate, the criteria used to determine which outlets would be invited nor answer if the media outlets invited included a range of faiths.</p><p data-block-key=\"4hfs8\">Religion News Service reported that it was invited to participate in the call, though it stated that the publication “is not a faith-based media organization, but rather a secular news service that covers religion, spirituality and ethics.”</p><p data-block-key=\"1ynjo\">RNS also included a list of publications that asked questions during the briefing call: the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Algemeiner (which covers Jewish and Israel news), World Magazine (which publicizes its content as “reporting the news from a Christian worldview”), America Magazine (“the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture”) and The Leaven, the newspaper of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas. CNN reported that a reporter with EWTN Global Catholic Television said the outlet was not originally invited but asked permission to participate.</p><p data-block-key=\"4drws\">In a statement sent to CNN, a State Department spokesperson said that while some press engagements, including department press briefings, teleconferences, briefings and sprays are open to any interested domestic or international press, that is not always the case. “Other engagements are more targeted or designed for topic, region, or audience-specific media. This has always been the case,” they said.</p><p data-block-key=\"i7cnv\">Former State Department spokesperson John Kirby, now a global affairs analyst for CNN, told the outlet that he has “certainly seen times when particular journalists or columnists have been targeted for inclusion on given topics.” However, “to exclude beat reporters from something as universally relevant as religious freedom in the Middle East strikes me as not only self-defeating but incredibly small-minded.”</p><p data-block-key=\"0dh1q\">Kirby also tweeted in response to news that no transcript of the briefing would be released. “This is absolutely not OK. Cabinet officials are public servants. They work for us. When they speak to reporters on the record everything they say—in its entirety—needs to be released at the earliest appropriate time,” he wrote.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-raw_html\"><blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\" data-lang=\"en\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">This is absolutely not OK. Cabinet officials are public servants. They work for us. When they speak to reporters on the record everything they say — in its entirety — needs to be released at the earliest appropriate time. That’s proper accountability. That’s what we deserve. <a href=\"https://t.co/OBJht2BaAK\">https://t.co/OBJht2BaAK</a></p>— John Kirby (@johnfkirby63) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/johnfkirby63/status/1107826830919327744?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">March 19, 2019</a></blockquote>\r\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"3p4of\">Standard norms are that when it concerns Cabinet-level officials like Pompeo, the department is expected to provide a transcript of the meeting remarks and a list of who attended to any interested journalist.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/RTS2DRM9.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"b0v3i\">The same day the State Department barred members of the press corps from an earlier briefing call with him, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks to the media on his plane after departing for the Middle East.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "District of Columbia",
"abbreviation": "DC"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [
"CNN",
"State Department Press Corps"
],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [
"Federal government: Agency"
],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Denial of Access"
],
"targeted_journalists": [],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": [
"Government event"
]
},
{
"title": "Judge orders ProPublica Illinois, other media, not to publish details of juvenile court case",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-orders-propublica-illinois-other-media-not-publish-details-juvenile-court-case/",
"first_published_at": "2019-03-27T17:42:06.855461Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-01-11T18:01:47.005478Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-01-11T18:01:46.921049Z",
"date": "2019-03-14",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Chicago",
"longitude": -87.65005,
"latitude": 41.85003,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"yk0h4\">On March 14, 2019, a Cook County Juvenile Court judge ordered ProPublica Illinois and other news organizations not to publish certain details about an ongoing child welfare case in the Chicago-based juvenile court.</p><p data-block-key=\"xyjws\">In the course of reporting on child welfare issues, a ProPublica Illinois reporter had learned about the case. On March 7, after the reporter tried to attend a hearing in the case, the hearing was closed to the public and press.</p><p data-block-key=\"ltia1\">Bruce Boyer — a Loyola University law professor whose legal clinic represents the foster children in the case — then requested that the court issue an order prohibiting news outlets from publishing details about the case. On March 14, Patricia Martin, the presiding judge of the juvenile court’s child protection division, granted the request and issued a prior restraint order.</p><p data-block-key=\"jd6zv\">Documents related to the juvenile court case, including Martin’s prior restraint order, have not been made public. But on March 19, ProPublica Illinois <a href=\"https://www.propublica.org/article/cook-county-judge-blocks-propublica-illinois-from-publishing-details-of-child-welfare-case\">reported on the existence of the prior restraint order</a>, describing it as an order “forbidding news organizations from publishing the names, addresses or any demographic information that would identify the children or the foster parents in a case ProPublica Illinois has been investigating.”</p><p data-block-key=\"2po47\">ProPublica Illinois was not initially a party to the case, but it asked the court to intervene in order to oppose the prior restraint order. On March 19, the court granted ProPublica Illinois’ motion to intervene, and on March 22, the news organization filed its opposition to the prior restraint order. A court hearing on the prior restraint order is now scheduled for April 5.</p><p data-block-key=\"12c1z\">Prior restraint orders are relatively unusual and should not be confused with sealing orders, which are far more commonly employed by courts. A sealing order is used when a court needs to allow attorneys and parties to a case access to sensitive information; the sealing order just prohibits the attorneys and parties from turning around and disclosing that information to the public. A prior restraint order is much more serious, since it prohibits a third party with no connection to the case (often a news organization) from publishing information that they learned on their own.</p><p data-block-key=\"lo76r\">ProPublica Illinois is opposing Martin’s prior restraint order because it sees it as an unconstitutional attempt by the government to interfere in its editorial process.</p><p data-block-key=\"m29a4\">“The Supreme Court has made it very clear that courts are not supposed to be editors,” ProPublica President Richard Tofel told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker. “One of the Constitution’s guarantees is that editors should be editors.”</p><p data-block-key=\"ogi9w\">Tofel is correct that legal precedent is on ProPublica Illinois’ side. In 1971, the Supreme Court famously ruled that the government’s attempts to prevent The New York Times and the Washington Post from publishing a classified history of the Vietnam War <a href=\"https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/403/713/\">violated the news organizations’ First Amendment rights</a>. This “Pentagon Papers” case established the precedent that, except in extreme circumstances, prior restraints on the press are unconstitutional.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": null,
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": "dropped",
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Illinois",
"abbreviation": "IL"
},
"updates": [
"(2019-04-15 13:33:00+00:00) Judge lifts some restrictions on publishing ban"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [
"Media",
"ProPublica Illinois"
],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Prior Restraint"
],
"targeted_journalists": [],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "Ohio political reporter removed from Democratic Party mailing list, reinstated by chair",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/ohio-political-reporter-removed-democratic-party-mailing-list-reinstated-chair/",
"first_published_at": "2019-05-09T15:52:01.899747Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-02-29T19:00:24.809537Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-02-29T19:00:24.677359Z",
"date": "2019-03-05",
"exact_date_unknown": true,
"city": "Cleveland",
"longitude": -81.69541,
"latitude": 41.4995,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"sgy3z\">Cleveland political reporter Seth Richardson was removed from the Ohio Democratic Party press release mailing list by staff in March 2019.</p><p data-block-key=\"k21lf\">Richardson posted a thread on Twitter that he had apparently been “frozen out” from covering the Ohio Democratic Party, and suggested he may have been removed from the press distribution list in response to his reporting.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-raw_html\"><blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\" data-lang=\"en\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">So I normally hate threads like these, but I've tried solving this privately and it feels like it deserves to be out there in the open. <a href=\"https://twitter.com/DavidPepper?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">@DavidPepper</a> and <a href=\"https://twitter.com/kirstinalv?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">@kirstinalv</a> are apparently trying to freeze me out of covering the <a href=\"https://twitter.com/OHDems?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">@OHDems</a> 1/</p>— Seth A. Richardson (@SethARichardson) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/SethARichardson/status/1125842409542307841?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">May 7, 2019</a></blockquote>\r\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"8s2di\">Richardson, who reports for Cleveland.com, noted that not receiving the press releases made it difficult for him to do his job.</p><p data-block-key=\"t63ll\">Ohio Democratic Party Chair David Pepper responded to Richardson on Twitter, and told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that he was not aware of the problem until he saw the tweets. Pepper confirmed that Richardson was added back to the press release list immediately.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-raw_html\"><blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\" data-lang=\"en\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">Seth, I was not aware of this and have already made clear you should be on the press list. <br><br>Take care.</p>— David Pepper (@DavidPepper) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/DavidPepper/status/1125854087088607233?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">May 7, 2019</a></blockquote>\r\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"hk8d2\">“Any suggestion that I requested a reporter be removed from an email list because of a story, general coverage or any other reason is false,” he said.</p><p data-block-key=\"5o8xo\">“We pride ourselves on not only being open to the press, but in supporting the freedom of the press at all levels,” Pepper wrote to the Tracker. “This was a poor decision made at a staff level that I immediately reversed when it came to my attention."</p><p data-block-key=\"oxcnb\">Pepper said that while there is not a written policy for removing reporters from the distribution, he said that practically, “we do not remove people from our press list,” and would never ask anyone to be removed. Pepper emphasized that the Ohio Democratic Party welcomes press coverage.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": null,
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Ohio",
"abbreviation": "OH"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [
"Democratic Party (state)"
],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Denial of Access"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Seth Richardson (Cleveland.com)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": null,
"type_of_denial": [
"Press credential or media list"
]
},
{
"title": "Sacramento Bee reporter detained while covering protest march",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-bee-reporter-detained-while-covering-protest-march/",
"first_published_at": "2020-03-12T15:56:38.779285Z",
"last_published_at": "2022-09-16T20:22:48.248210Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2022-09-16T20:22:48.167400Z",
"date": "2019-03-04",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Sacramento",
"longitude": -121.4944,
"latitude": 38.58157,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"kpbm0\">Sacramento Bee reporter Dale Kasler was one of three journalists arrested on March 4, 2019, in Sacramento, California, as police blocked off exits and began arresting those remaining at a protest march.</p><p data-block-key=\"bf7f7\">Then-Sacramento Business Journal reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/three-journalists-arrested-while-covering-stephon-clark-protest-sacramento/\">Scott Rodd</a> and California State University student reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/student-journalist-among-reporters-arrested-while-covering-sacramento-protest/\">William Coburn</a> were also arrested. A Bee photojournalist, Hector Amezcua, was <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-photojournalist-pushed-ground-police-while-covering-protest-his-camera-damaged/\">shoved to the ground by a bike officer</a> when police began to cordon protesters.</p><p data-block-key=\"f9xqy\">About 100 people gathered around 6:30 p.m. in East Sacramento to protest the district attorney’s decision not to bring criminal charges against officers in the 2018 shooting death of Stephon Clark, a 22-year-old black man. The march proceeded uneventfully and eventually circled back to where it had begun, in a Trader Joe’s parking lot in the Fab 40s neighborhood.</p><p data-block-key=\"0b6kt\">Police spokesperson Sgt. Vance Chandler <a href=\"https://www.npr.org/2019/03/05/700317892/police-arrest-84-after-stephon-clark-protest-in-east-sacramento\">told</a> NPR that officers gave 10 orders to disperse over a two-hour period. “Shortly after we started monitoring the group at [approximately] 7:30 p.m., we established the group was unlawfully assembling by standing in the street,” Chandler said.</p><p data-block-key=\"3uw64\">Protest organizers also reportedly encouraged attendees to leave, and many did. Soon after, however, a row of riot gear-clad officers formed a line and began slowly advancing while vans of bicycle officers blocked all side roads, leaving the only exit down 51st Street toward an overpass.</p><p data-block-key=\"vtj4t\">Kasler told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that a line of officers, unseeable at first, waited for them at the end of the bridge.</p><p data-block-key=\"vax7q\">Police had received reports that at least five cars had been keyed, according to a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/NormLeong/status/1102816147471196160\">tweet</a> from Sacramento Police Department Capt. Norm Leong, and shortly after 10 p.m. officers began arresting those that had not dispersed.</p><p data-block-key=\"hkkg5\">The Sacramento Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/crime/article227116519.html\">reported</a> that 84 people were arrested over the next four hours.</p><p data-block-key=\"dqaa2\">Kasler was live-streaming when two officers approached him and zip-tied his hands behind his back, placing his phone in his pants pocket. “I had held up my Bee badge and explained that I was a journalist but was taken into custody anyway,” Kasler <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article227127619.html\">wrote</a> in an account for The Bee.</p><p data-block-key=\"wmihe\">Within an hour, The Bee’s publisher and editor had made calls to have Kasler released. “Some higher-ups were summoned, I was pulled out of the line and my zip-ties were cut,” Kasler recounted.</p><p data-block-key=\"w41h5\">Kasler told the Tracker that after giving a brief statement to a sergeant he was given a certificate of release, on which the officer had checked the box for “arrestee exonerated.”</p><p data-block-key=\"gnwpb\">Reporters Rodd and Coburn were also zip-tied, and waited on a curb for 2 ½ hours before police loaded them onto vans heading to Cal Expo, a state fair ground, to be processed.</p><p data-block-key=\"hqad8\">The Sacramento County district attorney’s office announced a few days later that it would not charge those arrested at the protest, the San Francisco Chronicle <a href=\"https://www.sfchronicle.com/crime/amp/Stephon-Clark-demonstration-Sacramento-County-DA-13674720.php\">reported</a>. Sacramento's police department and public safety accountability office are conducting ongoing internal investigations into the police tactics used during the protest, The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article227124634.html\">reported</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"dt98e\">“I’m very disappointed the protest ended the way it did. I have many questions about what went on that precipitated the order to disperse and the subsequent arrests,” Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg <a href=\"https://twitter.com/Mayor_Steinberg/status/1102831149716451328\">tweeted</a> in the early morning on March 5. “No matter the reason an order to disperse was given, no member of the press should be detained for doing their job.”</p><p data-block-key=\"6esh6\">Kettling—surrounding protesters in order to prevent any exit, often followed by indiscriminate detentions and arrests—is used across the country as a protest response despite the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/blog/journalists-covering-protests-us-risk-getting-caught-police-kettling-tactic/\">risk it poses</a> to journalists covering the protest.</p><p data-block-key=\"cf7m8\">“I thought I had made it clear to them as they were detaining me that I was a reporter,” Kasler told the Tracker. “I was telling them that I’m with The Sacramento Bee and my colleagues on the other side of the police line, who were not detained, were shouting, ‘This is a reporter! This is a reporter! This is a reporter!’ And it didn’t seem to matter.”</p><p data-block-key=\"ryq2a\"><i>Editor’s Note: While Kasler told the Tracker that he was not told that he was under arrest nor read his Miranda rights, and his experience is widely considered a detainment, the Tracker documents it as an arrest. In our methodology, his detainment for an hour in a context where police had announced that those failing to disperse would be arrested — and were indiscriminately detaining those present ahead of processing — coupled with the certificate noting “arrestee exonerated,” categorizes his experience as an arrest.</i></p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Kasler_arrest_SacBee.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"l3edj\">Sacramento Bee reporter Dale Kasler, center, was live-streaming a planned protest when officers put him in flexible cuffs. Police arrested more than 80 people in conjunction with the march.</p>",
"arresting_authority": "Sacramento Police Department",
"arrest_status": "arrested and released",
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"Black Lives Matter",
"court verdict",
"kettle",
"protest"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Arrest/Criminal Charge"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Dale Kasler (The Sacramento Bee)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Student journalist among reporters arrested while covering Sacramento protest",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/student-journalist-among-reporters-arrested-while-covering-sacramento-protest/",
"first_published_at": "2020-03-12T15:51:33.353083Z",
"last_published_at": "2022-08-05T18:54:12.349624Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2022-08-05T18:54:12.280455Z",
"date": "2019-03-04",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Sacramento",
"longitude": -121.4944,
"latitude": 38.58157,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"x8asp\">William Coburn, a reporter for the California State University student newspaper, The State Hornet, was one of three journalists arrested while covering a protest march on March 4, 2019, in Sacramento, California.</p><p data-block-key=\"jnvfa\">Then-Sacramento Business Journal reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/three-journalists-arrested-while-covering-stephon-clark-protest-sacramento/\">Scott Rodd</a> and Sacramento Bee reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-bee-reporter-detained-while-covering-protest-march/\">Dale Kasler</a> were also arrested that night. A Bee photojournalist, Hector Amezcua, was <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-photojournalist-pushed-ground-police-while-covering-protest-his-camera-damaged/\">shoved to the ground</a> by a bike officer when police began to cordon protesters.</p><p data-block-key=\"b4wys\">About 100 people gathered around 6:30 p.m. in East Sacramento to protest the district attorney’s decision not to bring criminal charges against officers in the 2018 shooting death of Stephon Clark, a 22-year-old black man. The march proceeded uneventfully and eventually circled back to where it had begun, in a Trader Joe’s parking lot in the Fab 40s neighborhood.</p><p data-block-key=\"4vouz\">Coburn told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that the march had started uneventfully, and that fewer people had gathered than in the days after Clark was killed. After about two hours, the march circled back to the parking lot where it had begun.</p><p data-block-key=\"btkjn\">“It looked to me like the protest was winding down,” Coburn said.</p><p data-block-key=\"t96qd\">Police spokesperson Sgt. Vance Chandler <a href=\"https://www.npr.org/2019/03/05/700317892/police-arrest-84-after-stephon-clark-protest-in-east-sacramento\">told</a> NPR that officers gave 10 orders to disperse over a two-hour period. “Shortly after we started monitoring the group at [approximately] 7:30 p.m., we established the group was unlawfully assembling by standing in the street,” Chandler said.</p><p data-block-key=\"eh1zl\">Protest organizers also encouraged people to leave, Coburn said, and many did. Others were still mingling in the Trader Joe’s parking lot, including a few photographers, and Coburn joined them to conduct a few final interviews. Then, he said, a row of riot gear-clad officers formed a line and began slowly advancing, leaving the only exit down 51st Street.</p><p data-block-key=\"pe6tc\">“The police just started marching forward, taking a few steps and then stopping,” Coburn told the Tracker. “By stepping forward, we all started moving along 51st Street looking for places to get out, but all of them were blocked off, either by vans or by a few bike cops. It looked like it was just the two bike cops going over the overpass, so we assumed they just wanted us out of this neighborhood.”</p><p data-block-key=\"744k2\">A line of officers, unseeable at first, waited for them at the end of the bridge.</p><p data-block-key=\"ng2tp\">Police had received reports that at least five cars had been keyed, according to a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/NormLeong/status/1102816147471196160\">tweet</a> from Sacramento Police Department Capt. Norm Leong, and shortly after 10 p.m. officers began arresting those that had not dispersed.</p><p data-block-key=\"xhs30\">The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/crime/article227116519.html\">reported</a> that 84 people were arrested over the next four hours.</p><p data-block-key=\"tcciv\">Coburn told the Tracker that he had a professional camera around his neck, and when officers came to arrest him he said repeatedly that he was a reporter.</p><p data-block-key=\"7q3n9\">“After a while I just stopped saying [that I was a journalist] because they just didn’t know what to do about it,” he said.</p><p data-block-key=\"r0e4r\">While he was originally in handcuffs, Coburn told the Tracker that once officers sat him down on the curb they switched him into flexi-cuffs. He sat that way for 2 ½ hours before police loaded all those arrested into vans heading to Cal Expo, a state fair ground, to be processed.</p><p data-block-key=\"o8yk5\">After more than four hours in detention, Coburn was released around 2:30 a.m. on March 5 with a ticket for failure to disperse and a court hearing scheduled on June 4.</p><p data-block-key=\"ocmbl\">The Sacramento County district attorney’s office announced a few days later that it would not charge those arrested at the protest, the San Francisco Chronicle <a href=\"https://www.sfchronicle.com/crime/amp/Stephon-Clark-demonstration-Sacramento-County-DA-13674720.php\">reported</a>. Sacramento's police department and public safety accountability office are conducting ongoing internal investigations into the police tactics used during the protest, The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article227124634.html\">reported</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"gv4q0\">“I’m very disappointed the protest ended the way it did. I have many questions about what went on that precipitated the order to disperse and the subsequent arrests,” Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg <a href=\"https://twitter.com/Mayor_Steinberg/status/1102831149716451328\">tweeted</a> in the early morning on March 5. “No matter the reason an order to disperse was given, no member of the press should be detained for doing their job.”</p><p data-block-key=\"iu6rh\">Kettling—surrounding protesters in order to prevent any exit, often followed by indiscriminate detentions and arrests—is used across the country as a protest response despite the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/blog/journalists-covering-protests-us-risk-getting-caught-police-kettling-tactic/\">risk it poses</a> to journalists covering the protest.</p><p data-block-key=\"0opeh\"><i>Editor's Note: William Coburn originally reported to the Tracker that he was wearing university-issued press credentials when he was arrested, but it was later confirmed that he was not. This article was updated March 3, 2020.</i></p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Coburn.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"fnweb\">A line of police officers follow Sacramento, California, protesters who gathered in response to the district attorney’s decision to not prosecute officers after the shooting death of a young black man.</p>",
"arresting_authority": "Sacramento Police Department",
"arrest_status": "arrested and released",
"release_date": "2019-03-05",
"detention_date": "2019-03-04",
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"Black Lives Matter",
"court verdict",
"kettle",
"protest",
"student journalism"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Arrest/Criminal Charge"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"William Coburn (The [Sacramento State University] State Hornet)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Nevada judge orders online journalist to reveal sources, says not protected by shield law",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/nevada-judges-orders-online-journalist-reveal-sources-says-not-protected-shield-law/",
"first_published_at": "2019-03-23T20:27:58.242506Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-07-13T22:35:54.868665Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-07-13T22:35:54.741469Z",
"date": "2019-03-04",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Carson City",
"longitude": -119.7674,
"latitude": 39.1638,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"clpb0\">A Nevada state court judge issued an <a href=\"https://www.scribd.com/document/401772560/Order-on-Plaintiff-s-Motion-to-Compel#from_embed\">order</a> on March 4, 2019, to compel an online journalist to reveal his confidential sources, ruling that because he did not work for a print publication he did not qualify as a journalist—and was thus not covered by Nevada's shield law at the time.</p><p data-block-key=\"812aa\">Sam Toll founded the online news site <a href=\"http://thestoreyteller.online/\">the Storey Teller</a>, covering Storey County, Nevada, in February 2017 and joined the state press association in August 2017. Toll was sued for defamation in December 2017 by Lance Gilman, a Storey County commissioner and owner of the Mustang Ranch, a legal brothel. In five stories, published between April and December 2017, Toll published claims that Gilman lives outside of Storey County, meaning he fails to meet the residency requirement to hold county office under Nevada law. The defamation suit demands Toll produces the sources of any information he procured before August 2017.</p><p data-block-key=\"w5ph2\">Nevada's shield law—considered to be one of the most robust in the nation—states that "[n]o reporter, former reporter or editorial employee of any newspaper, periodical or press association ... may be required to disclose the source of any information procured or obtained by such person, in any legal proceedings, trial or investigation." But because this law was passed in 1969, some 14 years before the inception of the internet, it does not explicitly extend this protection to reporters for online publications.</p><p data-block-key=\"gxrmf\">In what has been criticized as an unduly narrow reading of the law, Judge James Wilson found that "[b]ecause Toll was not a reporter for a newspaper or press association before August of 2017 he was not covered by the news media privilege before August 2017, and therefore, the motion to compel must be granted as to any source of information obtained or procured by Toll before August of 2017."</p><p data-block-key=\"43nvj\">Wilson ruled that because the Storey Teller is an online-only publication, it "is not a newspaper and, therefore the news media privilege is not available to Toll under the 'reporter of a newspaper' provision of [Nevada's shield law]."</p><p data-block-key=\"o4liz\">In at least two other instances, Nevada courts have ruled that web-only publications were covered by the shield law, <a href=\"https://www.rgj.com/story/news/nation/2019/03/07/nevada-judge-rules-online-sites-not-protected-media-shield-law/3098026002/\">according</a> to the Reno Gazette Journal. “My understanding is that it’s the first ruling of its kind and actually conflicts with other rulings,” Richard Karpel, executive director of the Nevada Press Association, told the newspaper.</p><p data-block-key=\"8iky6\">Toll's lawyers filed a petition for writ of prohibition with the state Supreme Court on March 18. "While we respect Judge Wilson, we fundamentally disagree that an online journalist should be compelled to reveal their sources because they publish news articles in an online newspaper instead of traditional print newspaper," Luke Busby, one of Toll's attorneys, wrote in a statement. "Such a ruling undermines the protection of fundamental Constitutional principles of freedom of speech and of the press and stifles the free flow of information that is essential for any free society to exist."</p><p data-block-key=\"gjgwi\">On March 22, the Supreme Court stayed Gilman’s discovery request, pending review of Toll’s writ of prohibition. A deposition had been scheduled for March 25.</p><p data-block-key=\"x1cg4\">Other critics opined that Judge Wilson was splitting hairs in his order. "Unlike too many jobs in this country there is no such thing as a licensed journalist," newspaper columnist Thomas Mitchell <a href=\"https://elkodaily.com/opinion/columnists/thomas-mitchell-nevada-press-shield-law-protects-bloggers/article_431a34d6-e23f-5499-b2cf-30cfcc19edea.html\">wrote</a> in the Elko Daily Free Press.</p><p data-block-key=\"srgy3\">Toll told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that he would go to jail, if necessary, to protect his sources. But he worried that if this ruling stands, it could have a chilling effect on online media in Nevada.</p><p data-block-key=\"jj9vy\">"It would be potentially devastating for people who report on matters of public interest to not be able to protect whistleblowers," Toll said. "Do I relish going to jail? No. But for the people behind me, who currently have an online-only presence, I owe it to them to stand my ground."</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Toll_legal_order.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"loebp\">A Nevada judge has ruled that journalist Sam Toll is not protected under the state's shield laws because he publishes exclusively online.<br/></p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Nevada",
"abbreviation": "NV"
},
"updates": [
"(2019-12-05 16:03:00+00:00) Supreme Court of Nevada rules that shield law applies to digital media, too",
"(2020-03-19 09:16:00+00:00) Nevada state judge says online publisher can’t be further compelled for confidential sources",
"(2020-06-15 13:24:00+00:00) District judge dismisses defamation suit against Nevada digital reporter"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Sam Toll (The Storey Teller)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Three journalists arrested while covering Stephon Clark protest in Sacramento",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/three-journalists-arrested-while-covering-stephon-clark-protest-sacramento/",
"first_published_at": "2019-03-13T16:32:58.972095Z",
"last_published_at": "2022-08-05T18:51:24.769921Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2022-08-05T18:51:24.700540Z",
"date": "2019-03-04",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Sacramento",
"longitude": -121.4944,
"latitude": 38.58157,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"7elz1\">Sacramento Business Journal reporter Scott Rodd was one of three journalists arrested on March 4, 2019, in Sacramento, California, as police blocked off exits and began arresting those remaining at a protest march.</p><p data-block-key=\"yvh68\">Sacramento Bee reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-bee-reporter-detained-while-covering-protest-march/\">Dale Kasler</a> and California State University student reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/student-journalist-among-reporters-arrested-while-covering-sacramento-protest/\">William Coburn</a> were also arrested. A Bee photojournalist, Hector Amezcua, was <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-photojournalist-pushed-ground-police-while-covering-protest-his-camera-damaged/\">shoved to the ground</a> by a bike officer when police began to cordon protesters.</p><p data-block-key=\"zngfn\">About 100 people gathered around 6:30 p.m. in East Sacramento to protest the district attorney’s decision not to bring criminal charges against officers in the 2018 shooting death of Stephon Clark, a 22-year-old black man. The march proceeded uneventfully and eventually circled back to where it had begun, in a Trader Joe’s parking lot in the Fab 40s neighborhood.</p><p data-block-key=\"031ki\">Police spokesperson Sgt. Vance Chandler <a href=\"https://www.npr.org/2019/03/05/700317892/police-arrest-84-after-stephon-clark-protest-in-east-sacramento\">told</a> NPR that officers gave 10 orders to disperse over a two-hour period. “Shortly after we started monitoring the group at [approximately] 7:30 p.m., we established the group was unlawfully assembling by standing in the street,” Chandler said.</p><p data-block-key=\"u15h2\">Protest organizers also reportedly encouraged attendees to leave, and many did. Soon after, however, a row of riot gear-clad officers formed a line and began slowly advancing while vans of bicycle officers blocked all side roads, leaving the only exit down 51st Street.</p><p data-block-key=\"s5or9\">In a video Rodd shared on Twitter, police officers informed those present that they would be able to leave if they continued down 51st toward the overpass.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-tweet\"><div class=\"tweet-embed\">\n <div>\n <blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">The DA's office said it won't pursue charges against the 80+ people arrested at last week's <a href=\"https://twitter.com/hashtag/StephonClark?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">#StephonClark</a> protests.<br><br>But the city and PD are pursuing several investigations into what happened. I captured the protests at a pivotal moment when riot police were deployed.<br><br>(🔊 ON) <a href=\"https://t.co/wuu3YkX26M\">pic.twitter.com/wuu3YkX26M</a></p>— Scott Rodd (@SRodd_CPR) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/SRodd_CPR/status/1104821124947271681?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">March 10, 2019</a></blockquote>\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script>\n\n</div>\n\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"ndtja\">Police had received reports that at least five cars had been keyed, according to a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/NormLeong/status/1102816147471196160\">tweet</a> from Sacramento Police Department Capt. Norm Leong, and shortly after 10 p.m. officers began arresting those that had not dispersed.</p><p data-block-key=\"k8nys\">The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/crime/article227116519.html\">reported</a> that 84 people were arrested over the next four hours.</p><p data-block-key=\"j0e79\">Rodd and Coburn were among those zip-tied and left sitting on a curb for 2 ½ hours before police loaded them into vans heading to Cal Expo, a state fair ground, to be processed. The Bee’s Kasler was also zip-tied and detained, but released with a certificate of “arrestee exonerated.”</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-tweet\"><div class=\"tweet-embed\">\n <div>\n <blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">I also captured when police encircled protesters on the Highway 50 overpass after directing the group down 51st Street. <br><br>The video shows the moment police began arresting protesters--starting with several clergy members--and ends with my own arrest.<br><br>(🔊 ON) <a href=\"https://t.co/VROrCXKcNO\">pic.twitter.com/VROrCXKcNO</a></p>— Scott Rodd (@SRodd_CPR) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/SRodd_CPR/status/1104821128776769536?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">March 10, 2019</a></blockquote>\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script>\n\n</div>\n\n</div>\n</div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"fn2dr\">Rodd was wearing a black T-shirt with “PRESS” in bold, white letters across the front and back, and a hat displaying Sacramento Business Journal credentials. Rodd told his arresting officer and a second officer at the scene that he was a reporter, but neither reacted. Then, he said, he tried to continue doing his job.</p><p data-block-key=\"30syd\">“I started asking one of the officers questions about what precipitated the arrest, what situation made them decide that they needed to arrest people,” Rodd told the Tracker. “After a few questions the officer said, ‘I can’t answer those questions because you’re a member of the press and I’m not at liberty to talk about it.’ He acknowledged that I was a member of the press and I was there, I was in flexicuffs, I was detained, and it looked like I was going to be processed.”</p><p data-block-key=\"w67lt\">After more than four hours in detention, Rodd was released around 2:30 a.m. on March 5 with a ticket for failure to disperse and a court hearing scheduled on June 4.</p><p data-block-key=\"sawvf\">The Sacramento County district attorney’s office announced a few days later that it would not charge those arrested at the protest, the San Francisco Chronicle <a href=\"https://www.sfchronicle.com/crime/amp/Stephon-Clark-demonstration-Sacramento-County-DA-13674720.php\">reported</a>. Sacramento's police department and public safety accountability office are conducting ongoing internal investigations into the police tactics used during the protest, The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article227124634.html\">reported</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"s70ql\">“I’m very disappointed the protest ended the way it did. I have many questions about what went on that precipitated the order to disperse and the subsequent arrests,” Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg <a href=\"https://twitter.com/Mayor_Steinberg/status/1102831149716451328\">tweeted</a> in the early morning on March 5. “No matter the reason an order to disperse was given, no member of the press should be detained for doing their job.”</p><p data-block-key=\"dk9nh\">Kettling — surrounding protesters in order to prevent any exit, often followed by indiscriminate detentions and arrests — is used across the country as a protest response despite the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/blog/journalists-covering-protests-us-risk-getting-caught-police-kettling-tactic/\">risk it poses</a> to journalists covering the protest.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-image\">\n\n\n<img src=\"https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Stephon_Clark_Protest_Map.width-828.png\" width=\"828\" height=\"525\" alt=\"Courtesy Scott Rodd\">\n</div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"28e92\"><i>Journalist Scott Rodd created a map of the events around the protest and subsequent arrests. Key coloring and descriptions updated by the Tracker.</i><br/></p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": null,
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "",
"arresting_authority": "Sacramento Police Department",
"arrest_status": "arrested and released",
"release_date": "2019-03-05",
"detention_date": "2019-03-04",
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [
"(2019-04-25 11:55:00+00:00) Sacramento Police Department changes arrest status to detention"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"Black Lives Matter",
"court verdict",
"kettle",
"protest"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Arrest/Criminal Charge"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Scott Rodd (Sacramento Business Journal)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Sacramento photojournalist pushed to the ground by police while covering protest, his camera damaged",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-photojournalist-pushed-ground-police-while-covering-protest-his-camera-damaged/",
"first_published_at": "2019-03-13T16:09:06.811291Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-10-27T21:34:29.364734Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-10-27T21:34:29.244484Z",
"date": "2019-03-04",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Sacramento",
"longitude": -121.4944,
"latitude": 38.58157,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"warry\">A Sacramento police officer shoved Sacramento Bee Senior Photographer Hector Amezcua to the ground with his bicycle during a protest on March 4, 2019, breaking his equipment and interrupting his broadcast.</p><p data-block-key=\"96ztn\">More than 100 people gathered in a Trader Joe’s parking lot around 6:30 p.m. that day to protest the district attorney’s decision not to bring criminal charges against the officers who shot and killed Stephon Clark, a 22-year-old black man, last March. After about two hours, the march circled back to the parking lot where it had begun.</p><p data-block-key=\"0tfw3\">Police spokesperson Sgt. Vance Chandler <a href=\"https://www.npr.org/2019/03/05/700317892/police-arrest-84-after-stephon-clark-protest-in-east-sacramento\">told</a> NPR that officers gave 10 orders to disperse over a two-hour period. “Shortly after we started monitoring the group at [approximately] 7:30 p.m., we established the group was unlawfully assembling by standing in the street,” Chandler said.</p><p data-block-key=\"4g4rs\">Protest organizers also encouraged people to leave, NPR <a href=\"https://www.tpr.org/post/police-arrest-84-after-stephon-clark-protest-east-sacramento\">reported</a>, and many did. Soon after that, a row of officers in riot gear formed a line and began slowly advancing, leaving only one exit for those remaining: Down 51st Street.</p><p data-block-key=\"po98h\">Amezcua told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that he was broadcasting a livestream as officers on bicycles began pushing marchers into a flower bed next to a large Trader Joe’s sign. “As I hugged the corner of the sign with my right shoulder I felt bicycle officers closing in on me. I felt an officer hit me with his bike from my left side,” Amezcua said. “I lost my balance for a second and looked into [the] officer’s face as I turned. He screamed, ‘I told you to get out of the way,’ I assume as motive for hitting me.”</p><p data-block-key=\"v13ma\">He wasn’t aware that his camera had been damaged in the collision until his colleague Sam Stanton walked up to him to tell them they were no longer broadcasting live. The HDMI port and cable on his Nikon Z-6 camera were broken.</p><p data-block-key=\"uarmn\">The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/article227116989.html\">reported</a> that the assault was witnessed by National Lawyers Guild legal observers at the scene as well as Bee journalists.</p><p data-block-key=\"ewnt4\">Amezcua stayed behind at the shopping center where his company car was parked as officers on bikes and in riot gear began circling the protesters and forcing them on to 51st Street. When he and Stanton switched the live feed to his cellphone they continued reporting, staying around 20 feet behind the officers who continued cordoning the protesters onto the Highway 50 overpass. A line of officers, initially out of view of the protesters, was waiting at the end of the bridge.</p><p data-block-key=\"irpcx\">Police had received reports that at least five cars had been keyed, according to a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/NormLeong/status/1102816147471196160\">tweet</a> from Sacramento Police Department Capt. Norm Leong, and shortly after 10 p.m. officers began arresting those that had not dispersed.</p><p data-block-key=\"j1euk\">“As we walked closer we observed a large group of people on the overpass at 51st Street and Highway 50 surrounded by police officers on bikes and riot police with nowhere to go,” Amezcua said. “At this point I noticed our colleague Dale Kasler among those in the group.”</p><p data-block-key=\"2oxtk\">The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/crime/article227116519.html\">reported</a> that 84 people were arrested over the next four hours. The Tracker documented the arrests of three journalists, including Bee reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/sacramento-bee-reporter-detained-while-covering-protest-march/\">Kasler</a>, Sacramento Business Journal <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/three-journalists-arrested-while-covering-stephon-clark-protest-sacramento/\">reporter Scott Rodd</a> and <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/student-journalist-among-reporters-arrested-while-covering-sacramento-protest/\">student journalist William Coburn</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"5ok6o\">Amezcua told the Tracker that he believes that he, Stanton, and other journalists from Univision, KCRA, NPA and ABC 10 were not arrested because they had not stayed with the group that was corralled at the end of the overpass.</p><p data-block-key=\"5k2ol\">Kettling — surrounding protesters in order to prevent any exit, often followed by indiscriminate detentions and arrests — is used across the country as a protest response despite the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/blog/journalists-covering-protests-us-risk-getting-caught-police-kettling-tactic/\">risk it poses</a> to journalists covering the protest.</p><p data-block-key=\"oldg5\">“I’m very disappointed the protest ended the way it did. I have many questions about what went on that precipitated the order to disperse and the subsequent arrests,” Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg <a href=\"https://twitter.com/Mayor_Steinberg/status/1102831149716451328\">tweeted</a> in the early morning on March 5. “No matter the reason an order to disperse was given, no member of the press should be detained for doing their job.”</p><p data-block-key=\"ztt8c\">Sacramento's police department and public safety accountability office are conducting ongoing internal investigations into the police tactics used during the protest, The Bee <a href=\"https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article227124634.html\">reported</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"w1tz4\">Amezcua told the Tracker that people have asked him why they stayed after orders were given to disperse. “My response has been Section D of California PC 409.5,” Amezcua said.</p><p data-block-key=\"6hjlz\">That section of the penal code allows for any member of the news media to remain after orders to clear an area have been given.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/RTX5F32D.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"76wfh\">Sacramento police officers watch protesters in March 2018 following the funeral of Stephon Clark, a young black man. Protests broke out in 2019 after the announcement that officers involved in his shooting won’t be charged.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": "law enforcement",
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": "law enforcement",
"was_journalist_targeted": "unknown",
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [
{
"quantity": 1,
"equipment": "camera"
},
{
"quantity": 1,
"equipment": "miscellaneous equipment"
}
],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"Black Lives Matter",
"court verdict",
"protest"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Assault",
"Equipment Damage"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Hector Amezcua (The Sacramento Bee)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "San Francisco police seize multiple phone records of independent journalist Bryan Carmody",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/san-francisco-police-seize-multiple-phone-records-independent-journalist-bryan-carmody/",
"first_published_at": "2019-06-11T14:04:17.351126Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-03-14T21:39:24.736745Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-03-14T21:39:24.615220Z",
"date": "2019-03-01",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "San Francisco",
"longitude": -122.41942,
"latitude": 37.77493,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"5nre9\">In March and April 2019, San Francisco police seized phone records for freelance journalist Bryan Carmody as part of an investigation into one of Carmody’s confidential sources.</p><p data-block-key=\"4wy4y\">On May 31, the San Francisco Police Department formally notified Carmody that it had obtained a warrant to seize his mobile phone records. In a <a href=\"https://www.dropbox.com/s/czlyt7esf3te2w2/SFPD%20Certified%20Letter%20recd%205-31-19%20REDACTED%20by%20Bryan%20Carmody.pdf?dl=0\">letter to Carmody</a>, SFPD Sgt. Joseph Obidi wrote: “Mr. Carmody is being investigated as a co-conspirator in the theft of the San Francisco Police report, involving the death investigation of Jeff Adachi.”</p><p data-block-key=\"kh8bk\">Adachi, the San Francisco Public Defender, died unexpectedly on Feb. 22. Shortly after, Carmody obtained a copy of an SFPD report into Adachi’s death. The police report included salacious details about Adachi’s drug use and possible extramarital affair, and Carmody used the leaked report as the centerpiece of a story about Adachi’s death. Carmody sold his story on Adachi’s death to local TV news stations, who ran segments about the police report.</p><p data-block-key=\"q2cck\">Sgt. Obidi’s May 31 letter to Carmody stated that the SFPD had executed a search warrant on March 1 to compel Verizon to turn over Carmody’s mobile phone records, including “subscriber information, call detail records, SMS usage, mobile data usage, cell tower data,” for the period of time between 8:33 p.m. on Feb. 22 and 10:44 p.m. on Feb. 23.</p><p data-block-key=\"bholk\">On June 1, Carmody received <a href=\"https://www.dropbox.com/s/jxf0gcla14i6c9a/SFPD%20Certified%20Letter%20recd%206-1-19%20REDACTED%20by%20Bryan%20Carmody.pdf?dl=0\">two more letters</a> from Sgt. Obidi, notifying him that police had executed further warrants on March 13 and April 16 for his mobile phone records.</p><p data-block-key=\"b8pkz\">The March 13 warrant, like the earlier one executed on March 1, requested Verizon hand over Carmody’s mobile phone records for the same time period—between 8:33 p.m. on Feb. 22 and 10:44 p.m. on Feb. 23.</p><p data-block-key=\"d4lib\">The April 16 warrant was served on both Verizon and AT&T and requested that the two carriers hand over mobile phone records for three different phone numbers for the time period between 1:13 p.m. on April 12 and 11:59 p.m. on April 15.</p><p data-block-key=\"wzk50\">In addition to the warrants to seize Carmody’s mobile phone records, the SFPD obtained search warrants for Carmody’s home and office. On May 10, SFPD officers <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/san-francisco-police-use-search-warrant-raid-home-office-independent-journalist-source-material/\">raided Carmody’s home and office</a> and the reporter’s notebooks, computers, phones, and cameras.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screen_Shot_2019-06-11_at_10.01.1.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"y8cwv\">Through a certified letter after the fact, independent journalist Bryan Carmody learned of three separate search warrants executed on his phone records by the San Francisco police department.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": "Verizon, AT&T",
"third_party_business": "telecom company",
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [
"(2019-07-18 12:00:00+00:00) Judge quashes warrant used to seize phone records",
"(2020-05-26 14:51:00+00:00) San Francisco police agree to inform officers of press protections following raid",
"(2019-08-16 12:31:00+00:00) Judge quashes final warrant used in search of Bryan Carmody’s phone records",
"(2020-03-03 10:36:00+00:00) San Francisco to pay $369,000 for illegal raids of journalist Bryan Carmody",
"(2019-08-02 16:20:00+00:00) San Francisco judges quash three more warrants used in raid of independent journalist Bryan Carmody home, office and phone records"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Bryan Carmody (North Bay News)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "White House bars four print reporters from covering dinner between U.S., North Korea leaders",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/white-house-bars-four-print-reporters-covering-dinner-between-us-north-korea-leaders/",
"first_published_at": "2019-03-04T15:40:01.934331Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-11-25T18:48:30.211122Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-11-25T18:48:30.103654Z",
"date": "2019-02-27",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Hanoi",
"longitude": null,
"latitude": null,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"7k86o\">One day into President Trump’s diplomatic trip to Vietnam, the White House banned four U.S. journalists traveling in the press pool from covering the president’s dinner with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, The Washington Post <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/white-house-bans-four-journalists-from-covering-trump-kim-dinner-because-of-shouted-questions/2019/02/27/36e1d26c-3a8d-11e9-a2cd-307b06d0257b_story.html\">reported</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"cczxq\">On Feb. 27, 2019, shortly before the dinner was to take place in Hanoi, White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders told the press pool that only the photographers and news camera crews would be allowed to cover the dinner. After boisterous protests, including from pool photojournalists, Sanders conceded that one print reporter would be permitted to attend: Vivian Salama of The Wall Street Journal.</p><p data-block-key=\"na1yn\">The four pool reporters who were barred: Jonathan Lemire of The Associated Press, Jeff Mason of Reuters, Justin Sink of Bloomberg News, and Eli Stokols of the Los Angeles Times.</p><p data-block-key=\"oh2bz\">The Washington Post reported that when Sanders was asked why the journalists representing the three largest wire services and a major newspaper were excluded, she said that it was because of “sensitivities over shouted questions in the previous sprays.”</p><p data-block-key=\"iipdd\">During two brief photo opportunities on Wednesday night, American reporters—including Lemire and Mason—directed four questions at Trump; they asked Kim none. Trump and his aides have often complained about reporters asking the president questions during photo opportunities, particularly in the presence of foreign leaders.</p><p data-block-key=\"mgah2\">In November, the White House <a href=\"https://twitter.com/jamiedupree/status/1064632625598529537/photo/1\">issued</a> new press conduct guidelines and has occasionally punished reporters for their questioning, most notably CNN reporters <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/white-house-suspends-cnn-reporter-jim-acostas-press-credentials-and-falsely-accuses-him-manhandling-intern/\">Jim Acosta</a> and <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/white-house-bans-cnn-reporter-event-asking-inappropriate-questions/\">Kaitlan Collins</a>, the latter of whom was banned from attending an event in retaliation for trying to ask President Trump a question during a photo-op.</p><p data-block-key=\"xlp73\">Traditionally the White House has upheld the rights of journalists while a president is traveling overseas, particularly in instances where the president is meeting with leaders of a country where press freedom is limited or absent.</p><p data-block-key=\"4tedp\">LA Times Executive Editor Norman Pearlstine said in a <a href=\"https://www.latimes.com/world/la-fg-trump-kim-vietnam-summit-20190227-story.html\">statement</a>, “Previous administrations have often intervened to protect press access when foreign leaders have tried to limit coverage of presidential meetings abroad. The fact that this White House has done the opposite and excluded members of the press provides another sad example of its failure to uphold the American public’s right to see and be informed about President Trump’s activities.”</p><p data-block-key=\"fqc42\">In a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/whca/status/1100804535587692544\">statement</a>, Olivier Knox, White House Correspondents’ Association president, called the decision to exclude some of the journalists “capricious.” “This summit provides an opportunity for the American presidency to display its strength by facing vigorous questioning from a free and independent news media, not telegraph weakness by retreating behind arbitrary last-minute restrictions on coverage.”</p><p data-block-key=\"r3y1u\">Members of the press pool repeatedly asked Sanders whether North Korea was responsible for the restricted access, but she would not provide a direct answer. The ban came a day after the press pool was booted from the hotel where the White House had booked conference facilities to be used as a press workspace because Kim’s delegation had decided to stay at the same hotel.</p><p data-block-key=\"kqbpw\">In an emailed statement, Sanders said, “We are continuing to negotiate aspects of this historic summit and will always work to make sure the U.S. media has as much access as possible.”</p><p data-block-key=\"rb179\">The summit ended prematurely on Feb. 28.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/RTX6OZAM.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"oxrvt\">President Donald Trump, accompanied by Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, speaks at a news conference in Hanoi, Vietnam on Feb. 28. One day before, the White House barred four journalists from covering an event with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Vietnam",
"abbreviation": null
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"Donald Trump"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [
"Federal government: White House"
],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Denial of Access"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Eli Stokols (Los Angeles Times)",
"Jeff Mason (Reuters)",
"Jonathan Lemire (The Associated Press)",
"Justin Sink (Bloomberg News)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": [
"Government event"
]
},
{
"title": "Undercover police threaten to arrest journalist after he films the search of a black man",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/undercover-police-threaten-arrest-journalist-after-he-films-search-black-man/",
"first_published_at": "2019-04-04T17:27:07.090303Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-02-29T19:01:11.356912Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-02-29T19:01:11.266275Z",
"date": "2019-02-26",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Pittsburgh",
"longitude": -79.99589,
"latitude": 40.44062,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"6ri9b\">An undercover Pennsylvania State Police officer threatened to arrest a journalist when he noticed that the reporter was recording three officers’ search of a black man at an Amtrak station in Pittsburgh on Feb. 26, 2019.</p><p data-block-key=\"i8u4o\">Mike Elk, a reporter and founder of Payday Report, was returning to his hometown after a trip and had disembarked at the Pittsburgh station. In an account of the incident, Elk <a href=\"http://paydayreport.com/pa-police-threatened-me-with-arrest-for-recording-search-of-a-black-man/\">wrote</a> for the labor publication that he was heading toward the exit when he noticed three undercover state police officers corner and begin searching a black man. He said he followed his journalistic instinct and began to record the interaction.</p><p data-block-key=\"3id13\">After the officers finished searching the man’s bags and released him, Elk told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that an officer saw that he was recording and approached him, demanding to see his identification while the two other undercover officers “hovered” nearby. Elk identified himself as a journalist and told the officer that he felt within his rights to record them in a public space.</p><p data-block-key=\"e3nzg\">“The undercover cop told me that I was illegally wiretapping him,” Elk wrote in his account. The officer noted that Elk’s breath smelled of alcohol—Elk wrote that he had three Bud Lites on the train—and that he could be arrested for public intoxication as soon as he stopped outside the station.</p><p data-block-key=\"6hok1\">When the officer repeated his demand that Elk show him identification, Elk handed the officer his passport, which Elk said was in his back pocket as he had just returned from Portugal. Elk wrote that the officer mocked him as “fancy” for having a passport, demanded to see his driver’s license and repeated his threat to arrest Elk once he left the train station.</p><p data-block-key=\"kt6v1\">“I showed [my driver’s license] to him and he said we are gonna check to see if they [sic] are any warrants out for your arrest,” Elk recounted.</p><p data-block-key=\"yv9yt\">Elk volunteered to erase the video he had taken of the officers’ interaction with the black man. “I informed the officer that I would erase the recording. Three cops crowded around me and watched as I deleted it,” Elk wrote. However, he continued, “the threats continued even after I erased the recording.</p><p data-block-key=\"mjqrj\">Elk wrote that after a few minutes he and the officer threatening arrest came to an agreement to walk away. A different officer approached him then and told Elk, “Why do you fuck with us? Don’t fuck with us and we won’t fuck with you.”</p><p data-block-key=\"teg8a\">Elk said he was able to leave the station approximately five minutes after he had disembarked from the train. Elk wrote that he has reached out to the American Civil Liberties Union and plans to take legal action in order to assert the rights of journalists, and the public generally, to record incidents involving the police in public spaces.</p><p data-block-key=\"ltybw\">“This is my hometown and I am not gonna be intimidated for standing up for racial justice,” Elk wrote.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Elk_amtrakstation2.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"g1668\">Inside this Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Amtrak station journalist Mike Elk filmed undercover state police interaction with a black man, seen in the left corner.<br/></p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Pennsylvania",
"abbreviation": "PA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Other Incident"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Mike Elk (Payday Report)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "Judge quashes energy company’s subpoena of former Post-Gazette managing editor",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-quashes-energy-companys-subpoena-of-former-post-gazette-managing-editor/",
"first_published_at": "2023-04-21T15:56:34.603719Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-04-21T16:12:24.646725Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-04-21T16:12:24.546612Z",
"date": "2019-02-25",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Pittsburgh",
"longitude": -79.99589,
"latitude": 40.44062,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"q5flo\">Staff of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette were subpoenaed in February 2019 by Range Resources while reporting around a confidential settlement between the gas-drilling company and Pennsylvania residents. On May 3, a Washington County judge <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/2019/05/07/Range-Resources-Haney-settlement-shield-law-Washington-County/stories/201905070115\">quashed the requests</a> for testimony, sources, notes and documents from former Post-Gazette Managing Editor Sally Stapleton and two reporters.</p><p data-block-key=\"3gmks\">Beginning in January, the Post-Gazette sought to unseal an August 2018 <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/environment/2019/02/07/Post-Gazette-asks-court-to-unseal-Haney-shale-gas-case-settlement/stories/201902070186\">settlement</a> between Range and families who alleged they had experienced serious health problems due to exposure to leaks, spills and air pollution emanating from a nearby company well. Range fought the outlet’s petition, claiming the request was not timely.</p><p data-block-key=\"cfben\">Range lawyers subpoenaed Stapleton and reporters <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-judge-denies-energy-companys-subpoena-of-pittsburgh-post-gazette-staff/\">Don Hopey</a> and <a href=\"/all-incidents/judge-quashes-energy-companys-subpoena-of-post-gazette-reporter-staff/\">David Templeton</a> on Feb. 25 to uncover the reporters’ sources and obtain their notes and documents related to the case, the Post-Gazette <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/2019/05/07/Range-Resources-Haney-settlement-shield-law-Washington-County/stories/201905070115\">reported</a>. The outlet entered its objection to all three subpoenas on March 11, according to the court docket.</p><p data-block-key=\"9is5t\">In her May ruling quashing the subpoenas, Washington County Common Pleas Court President Judge Katherine Emery cited Pennsylvania’s shield law and its protection of news sources.</p><p data-block-key=\"51s37\">“The Shield Law must be liberally construed in favor of the news media,” Emery wrote in her order and opinion. “Under this law, the employees of the newspaper cannot be required to disclose any information that could lead to the disclosure of their sources.”</p><p data-block-key=\"b3pi1\">The Post-Gazette also asked Emery to order Range to cover the newspaper’s legal fees, calling the subpoenas “a brazen and legally abusive attempt to harass and intimidate the Post-Gazette.” Emery denied that request.</p><p data-block-key=\"2jl6t\">In a related incident, the same judge barred Pittsburgh-based reporter Reid Frazier <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-journalist-barred-publishing-document-mistakenly-made-public-order-vacated/\">from directly or indirectly publishing</a> contents of the settlement terms on May 30, which the reporter had inadvertently obtained from a glitch in the court’s software. On June 4, Range told Emery it would publicly release the settlement terms, <a href=\"https://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2019/06/04/court-document-reveals-range-resources-other-defendants-agreed-to-3-million-settlement-in-washington-county-contamination-suit/\">Frazier reported</a>, effectively ending the Post-Gazette’s court action to unseal it and the publishing injunction. Read more on the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-journalist-barred-publishing-document-mistakenly-made-public-order-vacated/\">prior restraint here</a>.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": null,
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": "journalist communications or work product",
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Pennsylvania",
"abbreviation": "PA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"environmentalism"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Sally Stapleton (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [
"quashed"
],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Judge quashes energy company’s subpoena of Post-Gazette reporter, staff",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-quashes-energy-companys-subpoena-of-post-gazette-reporter-staff/",
"first_published_at": "2023-04-21T16:03:01.557446Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-04-21T16:12:10.464911Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-04-21T16:12:10.372777Z",
"date": "2019-02-25",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Pittsburgh",
"longitude": -79.99589,
"latitude": 40.44062,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"vhf5n\">Staff of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette were subpoenaed in February 2019 by Range Resources while reporting around a confidential settlement between the gas-drilling company and Pennsylvania residents. On May 3, a Washington County judge <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/2019/05/07/Range-Resources-Haney-settlement-shield-law-Washington-County/stories/201905070115\">quashed the requests</a> for testimony, sources, notes and documents from former Post-Gazette reporter David Templeton and two other journalists.</p><p data-block-key=\"6llg\">Beginning in January, the Post-Gazette sought to unseal an August 2018 <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/environment/2019/02/07/Post-Gazette-asks-court-to-unseal-Haney-shale-gas-case-settlement/stories/201902070186\">settlement</a> between Range and families who alleged they had experienced serious health problems due to exposure to leaks, spills and air pollution emanating from a nearby company well. Range fought the outlet’s petition, claiming the request was not timely.</p><p data-block-key=\"c5st4\">Range lawyers subpoenaed Templeton, reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-judge-denies-energy-companys-subpoena-of-pittsburgh-post-gazette-staff/\">Don Hopey</a> and former Managing Editor <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-quashes-energy-companys-subpoena-of-former-post-gazette-managing-editor/\">Sally Stapleton</a> on Feb. 25 to uncover the reporters’ sources and obtain their notes and documents related to the case, the Post-Gazette <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/2019/05/07/Range-Resources-Haney-settlement-shield-law-Washington-County/stories/201905070115\">reported</a>. The outlet entered its objection to all three subpoenas on March 11, according to the court docket.</p><p data-block-key=\"205sk\">In her May ruling quashing the subpoenas, Washington County Common Pleas Court President Judge Katherine Emery cited Pennsylvania’s shield law and its protection of news sources.</p><p data-block-key=\"6ua5e\">“The Shield Law must be liberally construed in favor of the news media,” Emery wrote in her order and opinion. “Under this law, the employees of the newspaper cannot be required to disclose any information that could lead to the disclosure of their sources.”</p><p data-block-key=\"crhkh\">The Post-Gazette also asked Emery to order Range to cover the newspaper’s legal fees, calling the subpoenas “a brazen and legally abusive attempt to harass and intimidate the Post-Gazette.” Emery denied that request.</p><p data-block-key=\"ab8su\">In a related incident, the same judge barred Pittsburgh-based reporter Reid Frazier <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-journalist-barred-publishing-document-mistakenly-made-public-order-vacated/\">from directly or indirectly publishing</a> contents of the settlement terms on May 30, which the reporter had inadvertently obtained from a glitch in the court’s software. On June 4, Range told Emery it would publicly release the settlement terms, <a href=\"https://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2019/06/04/court-document-reveals-range-resources-other-defendants-agreed-to-3-million-settlement-in-washington-county-contamination-suit/\">Frazier reported</a>, effectively ending the Post-Gazette’s court action to unseal it and the publishing injunction. Read more on the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-journalist-barred-publishing-document-mistakenly-made-public-order-vacated/\">prior restraint here</a>.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": null,
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": "journalist communications or work product",
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Pennsylvania",
"abbreviation": "PA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"environmentalism"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"David Templeton (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [
"quashed"
],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Pennsylvania judge denies energy company’s subpoena of Pittsburgh Post-Gazette staff",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-judge-denies-energy-companys-subpoena-of-pittsburgh-post-gazette-staff/",
"first_published_at": "2019-06-06T14:55:26.942635Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-04-21T16:14:22.245205Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-04-21T16:14:22.121937Z",
"date": "2019-02-25",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Pittsburgh",
"longitude": -79.99589,
"latitude": 40.44062,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"9kh0o\">Staff of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette were subpoenaed in February 2019 by Range Resources while reporting around a confidential settlement between the gas-drilling company and Pennsylvania residents. On May 3, a Washington County judge <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/2019/05/07/Range-Resources-Haney-settlement-shield-law-Washington-County/stories/201905070115\">quashed the requests</a> for testimony, sources, notes and documents from former Post-Gazette reporter Don Hopey and two other journalists. </p><p data-block-key=\"78a8t\">Beginning in January, the Post-Gazette sought to unseal an August 2018 <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/environment/2019/02/07/Post-Gazette-asks-court-to-unseal-Haney-shale-gas-case-settlement/stories/201902070186\">settlement</a> between Range and families who alleged they had experienced serious health problems due to exposure to leaks, spills and air pollution emanating from a nearby company well. Range fought the outlet’s petition, claiming the request was not timely. </p><p data-block-key=\"dum7l\">Range lawyers subpoenaed Hopey, reporter <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-quashes-energy-companys-subpoena-of-post-gazette-reporter-staff/\">David Templeton</a> and former Managing Editor <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/judge-quashes-energy-companys-subpoena-of-former-post-gazette-managing-editor/\">Sally Stapleton</a> on Feb. 25 to uncover the reporters’ sources and obtain their notes and documents related to the case, the Post-Gazette <a href=\"https://www.post-gazette.com/news/2019/05/07/Range-Resources-Haney-settlement-shield-law-Washington-County/stories/201905070115\">reported</a>. The outlet entered its objection to all three subpoenas on March 11, according to the court docket.</p><p data-block-key=\"444k4\">In her May ruling quashing the subpoenas, Washington County Common Pleas Court President Judge Katherine Emery cited Pennsylvania’s shield law and its protection of news sources. </p><p data-block-key=\"2a0lg\">“The Shield Law must be liberally construed in favor of the news media,” Emery wrote in her order and opinion. “Under this law, the employees of the newspaper cannot be required to disclose any information that could lead to the disclosure of their sources.”</p><p data-block-key=\"bsqa\">The Post-Gazette also asked Emery to order Range to cover the newspaper’s legal fees, calling the subpoenas “a brazen and legally abusive attempt to harass and intimidate the Post-Gazette.” Emery denied that request.</p><p data-block-key=\"dbsq6\">In a related incident, the same judge barred Pittsburgh-based reporter Reid Frazier <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-journalist-barred-publishing-document-mistakenly-made-public-order-vacated/\">from directly or indirectly publishing</a> contents of the settlement terms on May 30, which the reporter had inadvertently obtained from a glitch in the court’s software. On June 4, Range told Emery it would publicly release the settlement terms, <a href=\"https://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2019/06/04/court-document-reveals-range-resources-other-defendants-agreed-to-3-million-settlement-in-washington-county-contamination-suit/\">Frazier reported</a>, effectively ending the Post-Gazette’s court action to unseal it and the publishing injunction. Read more on the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/pennsylvania-journalist-barred-publishing-document-mistakenly-made-public-order-vacated/\">prior restraint here</a>. </p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screen_Shot_2019-06-06_at_10.48.5.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"mooo6\">A notice of deposition to Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reporter Don Hopey, one of three people in the newsroom to ordered to turn over work product, stemming from the paper's request to unseal a private settlement.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": "journalist communications or work product",
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Pennsylvania",
"abbreviation": "PA"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"environmentalism"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Don Hopey (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [
"quashed"
],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "CBS San Francisco photographer robbed at gunpoint, security guard shot",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/cbs-san-francisco-photographer-robbed-at-gunpoint-security-guard-shot/",
"first_published_at": "2021-10-22T17:53:00.617276Z",
"last_published_at": "2024-09-09T21:12:56.367633Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2024-09-09T21:12:56.250267Z",
"date": "2019-02-24",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Oakland",
"longitude": -122.2708,
"latitude": 37.80437,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"bcgjp\">John Anglin, a photographer for San Francisco-based local CBS KPIX 5 news, was robbed at gunpoint early in the evening on Feb. 24, 2019, while covering the Oakland teachers’ strike.</p><p data-block-key=\"eho60\">Having just finished gathering interviews around 5 p.m., Anglin was standing outside his news van when two men pulled up in a car, KPIX <a href=\"https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2019/02/25/armed-robbery-attack-kpix-news-crew-oakland/\">reported</a>. The men got out and one held a gun to Anglin’s head, demanding their camera.</p><p data-block-key=\"yah4k\">In a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/joenewsman/status/1099875256465010690\">video</a> posted online, Anglin states, “He came out of the car with a gun in hand, basically saying, ‘Give up the camera, I want the camera.’ I just walked away and said, ‘Take it, it’s yours.’”</p><p data-block-key=\"lgb2v\">Anglin surrendered the equipment, according to a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/joenewsman/status/1099875256465010690\">tweet</a> from KPIX 5 reporter Joe Vazquez, and took cover in the news van.</p><p data-block-key=\"uc4pu\">Matt Meredith, a retired Berkeley police officer, was accompanying the news crew as a private security guard. Meredith exchanged fire with the suspect and was shot in the upper leg before the suspects fled.</p><p data-block-key=\"m21bc\">Meredith was transported to Highland Hospital where he was treated. He has since been released and is expected to recover, Oakland Police spokesperson Johnna Watson told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker.</p><p data-block-key=\"1oxdu\">This is not the first time that a news crew has been targeted for theft in the San Francisco area. Violent robberies targeting news crews became a consistent problem beginning in 2011 during the Occupy Wall Street movement, KPIX <a href=\"https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2019/02/25/armed-robbery-attack-kpix-news-crew-oakland/\">reported</a>, which has motivated many Bay area television stations to hire private security to accompany their teams in the field.</p><p data-block-key=\"9t6y6\">In July 2015, NBC Bay Area <a href=\"https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/NBC-Bay-Area-News-Crew-Mugged-Pistol-Whipped-at-San-Francisco-Pier-311452221.html\">reported</a> that two of their journalists and a reporter from KTVU were attacked and robbed in the early morning while preparing to go on air at Pier 14, a popular tourist designation, in San Francisco. A KPIX photojournalist was also <a href=\"https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2012/11/08/cbs-5-cameraman-beaten-robbed-after-oakland-live-shot/\">attacked and robbed</a> by a group of young men after broadcasting live in front of a school in Oakland in November 2012.</p><p data-block-key=\"q723r\">Watson confirmed that multiple suspects have been arrested in connection with the Feb. 24 robbery, but neither the names of the suspects nor charges will be released until the District Attorney’s Office formally files charges.</p><p data-block-key=\"16q1b\">Watson told the Tracker that at 5:15 p.m. on that day a suspect walked into a nearby hospital seeking treatment for several gunshot wounds and was arrested in connection with the robbery and shooting. Later that evening Oakland police also pursued another suspect driving a car connected with the robbery and detained the driver.</p><p data-block-key=\"v3aah\">As a result of the arrests, the stolen camera was recovered, and the investigation is ongoing.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screenshot_2019-02-25_12.55.07.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"5ivml\">This screenshot from California-based KPIX 5 reporter, Joe Vazquez, shows the news team's security guard being transported after receiving a gunshot wound to the leg. He is expected to recover.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": "private individual",
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": "private individual",
"was_journalist_targeted": "yes",
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [
{
"quantity": 1,
"equipment": "camera"
}
],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [
"(2021-10-18 00:00:00+00:00) Two convicted in attempted robbery of San Francisco news crew"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"robbery"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Assault",
"Equipment Damage"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"John Anglin (KPIX-TV)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "CBS San Francisco news reporter robbed at gunpoint, security guard shot",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/cbs-san-francisco-news-crew-robbed-gunpoint-its-security-guard-shot/",
"first_published_at": "2019-02-28T20:13:08.480713Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-02-21T15:20:14.276975Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-02-21T15:20:14.135287Z",
"date": "2019-02-24",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Oakland",
"longitude": -122.2708,
"latitude": 37.80437,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"xovns\">Joe Vazquez, a reporter for San Francisco-based local CBS KPIX 5 News was robbed at gunpoint early in the evening on Feb. 24, 2019, while covering the Oakland teachers’ strike.</p><p data-block-key=\"3ae6r\">Having just finished gathering interviews around 5 p.m., Vazquez was standing outside his news van with photographer John Anglin when two men pulled up in a car, KPIX <a href=\"https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2019/02/25/armed-robbery-attack-kpix-news-crew-oakland/\">reported</a>. The men got out and one held a gun to Anglin’s head, demanding their camera.</p><p data-block-key=\"hr2gg\">According to a <a href=\"https://twitter.com/joenewsman/status/1099875256465010690\">tweet</a> from Vazquez the men took cover in the news van with Vazquez, telling him to get down.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-raw_html\"><blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\" data-lang=\"en\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">Thank you, friends, for your well wishes. Our guard was shot today in Oakland while we were on assignment covering the Oakland teachers strike. We believe his wounds are not life threatening, thank God. Photographer John Anglin was robbed at gunpoint. 1/3 <a href=\"https://t.co/TP225CUJNQ\">pic.twitter.com/TP225CUJNQ</a></p>— Joe Vazquez (@joenewsman) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/joenewsman/status/1099871095723765760?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">February 25, 2019</a></blockquote>\r\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"j6q6m\">In July 2015, NBC Bay Area <a href=\"https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/NBC-Bay-Area-News-Crew-Mugged-Pistol-Whipped-at-San-Francisco-Pier-311452221.html\">reported</a> that two of their journalists and a reporter from KTVU were attacked and robbed in the early morning while preparing to go on air at Pier 14, a popular tourist designation, in San Francisco. A KPIX photojournalist was also <a href=\"https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2012/11/08/cbs-5-cameraman-beaten-robbed-after-oakland-live-shot/\">attacked and robbed</a> by a group of young men after broadcasting live in front of a school in Oakland in November 2012.</p><p data-block-key=\"y2kx5\">Watson confirmed that multiple suspects have been arrested in connection with the Feb. 24 robbery, but neither the names of the suspects nor charges will be released until the District Attorney’s Office formally files charges.</p><p data-block-key=\"i2j6c\">Watson told the Tracker that at 5:15 p.m. on that day a suspect walked into a nearby hospital seeking treatment for several gunshot wounds and was arrested in connection with the robbery and shooting. Later that evening Oakland police pursued another suspect driving a car connected with the robbery and detained the driver.</p><p data-block-key=\"rx31g\">As a result of the arrests, the stolen camera was recovered, and the investigation is ongoing.</p></div>\n<div class=\"block-raw_html\"><blockquote class=\"twitter-tweet\" data-lang=\"en\"><p lang=\"en\" dir=\"ltr\">Update: The Oakland Police Department can confirm at least 2 arrests have been made in conn. with the armed robbery of a Bay Area news crew and the shooting of the crew’s security guard (2/24/19). Film camera recovered. Guard treated for gunshot wound & released from hospital. <a href=\"https://t.co/Ptpr0c7Sr0\">pic.twitter.com/Ptpr0c7Sr0</a></p>— Oakland Police Dept. (@oaklandpoliceca) <a href=\"https://twitter.com/oaklandpoliceca/status/1100078096131141632?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw\">February 25, 2019</a></blockquote>\r\n<script async src=\"https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"></script></div>\n<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"i2xpa\">“We heard a flurry of loud gunshots. Very close! More shots, I saw a guy drag the camera away and saw our guard Matt was hit,” Vazquez wrote.</p><p data-block-key=\"yr4ft\">Matt Meredith, a retired Berkeley police officer, was accompanying the news crew as a private security guard. Meredith exchanged fire with the suspect and was shot in the upper leg before the suspects fled.</p><p data-block-key=\"8tj7z\">“The security guard says he turned to run to retreat, there were no words exchanged, the gunman came straight up and shot him,” Vazquez told KPIX.</p><p data-block-key=\"fzajs\">Meredith was transported to Highland Hospital where he was treated. He has since been released and is expected to recover, Oakland Police spokesperson Johnna Watson told the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker.</p><p data-block-key=\"9hwp0\">This is not the first time that a news crew has been targeted for theft in the San Francisco area. Violent robberies targeting news crews became a consistent problem beginning in 2011 during the Occupy Wall Street movement, KPIX <a href=\"https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2019/02/25/armed-robbery-attack-kpix-news-crew-oakland/\">reported</a>, which has motivated many Bay area television stations to hire private security to accompany their teams in the field.</p><p data-block-key=\"1v3fl\">As a result of the arrests, the stolen camera was recovered, and the investigation is ongoing.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screenshot_2019-02-25_12.55.07.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"4ea47\">This screenshot from California-based KPIX 5 reporter, Joe Vazquez, shows the news team's security guard being transported after receiving a gunshot wound to the leg. He is expected to recover.</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": "private individual",
"was_journalist_targeted": "yes",
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": null,
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": null,
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "California",
"abbreviation": "CA"
},
"updates": [
"(2021-10-18 00:00:00+00:00) Two convicted in attempted robbery of San Francisco news crew"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [
"robbery"
],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Assault"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Joe Vazquez (KPIX-TV)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [],
"type_of_denial": null
},
{
"title": "Second subpoena issued for content of Illinois watchdog’s Dropbox account",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/second-subpoena-issued-for-content-of-illinois-watchdogs-dropbox-account/",
"first_published_at": "2020-02-25T21:23:39.708099Z",
"last_published_at": "2025-03-13T14:23:32.158870Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2025-03-13T14:23:32.066610Z",
"date": "2019-02-22",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Algonquin Township",
"longitude": null,
"latitude": null,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"vq5vm\">A lawyer representing Algonquin Township, Illinois, filed a second subpoena to compel the file-hosting service Dropbox to produce information on an account belonging to the Edgar County Watchdogs, an Illinois-based government watchdog blog.</p><p data-block-key=\"zzc5z\">The <a href=\"https://secureservercdn.net/198.71.233.197/7b1.61b.myftpupload.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/19.02.22.Subpoena-for-Production-of-Business-Records.Dropbox.pdf\">subpoena</a>, issued on Feb. 22, 2019, requested much of the same information as the <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/subpoena-issued-contents-illinois-government-watchdogs-dropbox-account/\">first subpoena</a> filed in January — the content, IP and email addresses of all users, users’ access histories, payment information and comments of the account.</p><p data-block-key=\"ovk3e\">The outlet is currently suing Algonquin Township for failing to provide records in response to 16 different public records requests, and the subpoena was issued in the context of that lawsuit.</p><p data-block-key=\"lluhq\">Edgar County Watchdogs <a href=\"https://edgarcountywatchdogs.com/2019/03/algonquin-township-attacks-media-a-second-time-subpoenas-for-our-dropbox-account-again/\">reported</a> it filed a motion to quash the subpoena, which was heard in March.</p><p data-block-key=\"0ma6m\">“Illinois law protects media and reporters from things like this, but the Township Board has decided to keep piling on and incurring more legal bills,” blog co-founder John Kraft wrote. “Not just their own legal bills, but the township will also pay our legal bills when they lose this FOIA lawsuit.”</p><p data-block-key=\"sgf8f\">In March, a McHenry County Court judge granted a stay in the production of the requested materials until a ruling could be made on the motion to quash, Edgar County Watchdogs <a href=\"https://edgarcountywatchdogs.com/2019/03/mchenry-county-judge-ordered-stay-of-production-in-algonquin-townships-subpoena-to-watchdogs-dropbox/\">reported</a>. The judge also confirmed that the first subpoena was quashed.</p><p data-block-key=\"dezak\">Edgar County Watchdogs shared court documents with the U.S. Press Freedom Tracker that show the motion to quash was denied on April 16, but the outlet filed a motion for the judge to reconsider.</p><p data-block-key=\"k6h96\">Kraft told the Tracker that the subpoenas would have a serious impact on the outlet if it weren’t for the support of other organizations, like the Press Freedom Defense Fund.</p><p data-block-key=\"zqpvj\">“We do not have the money to hire an attorney and do the paperwork to fight these subpoenas. Without these grants we wouldn’t be able to do it,” Kraft said. “We’d have to roll over and give them what they ask for.”</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/ECW_Dropbox2.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.png",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"fifid\">A portion of a subpoena for the Edgar County Watchdog's Dropbox account information</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": "journalist communications or work product",
"name_of_business": "Dropbox",
"third_party_business": "tech company",
"legal_order_venue": "State",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Illinois",
"abbreviation": "IL"
},
"updates": [
"(2019-07-10 16:08:00+00:00) Judge quashes subpoena for third-party work product, citing the state's reporter's privilege"
],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [
"Edgar County Watchdogs"
],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [],
"subpoena_statuses": [
"quashed"
],
"type_of_denial": []
},
{
"title": "New Yorker staff writer subpoenaed for 'all documents' around 2014 article",
"url": "https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/new-yorker-staff-writer-subpoenaed-all-documents-around-2014-article/",
"first_published_at": "2019-11-08T18:03:06.675628Z",
"last_published_at": "2023-07-05T19:03:54.367789Z",
"latest_revision_created_at": "2023-07-05T19:03:54.250367Z",
"date": "2019-02-22",
"exact_date_unknown": false,
"city": "Chicago",
"longitude": -87.65005,
"latitude": 41.85003,
"body": "<div class=\"block-rich_text\"><p data-block-key=\"v59tn\">In February, attorneys representing the city of Chicago subpoenaed The New Yorker staff writer Nicholas Schmidle to produce documents in relation to an article published in the magazine in 2014.</p><p data-block-key=\"zl5e3\">A set of separate <a href=\"https://pressfreedomtracker.us/all-incidents/new-yorker-staff-writer-subpoenaed-testimony-civil-rights-lawsuit/\">subpoenas for the reporter’s testimony</a> was served in June and quashed in October.</p><p data-block-key=\"d8x17\">In 2014, Schmidle wrote a <a href=\"https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/08/04/crime-fiction\">feature story for the New Yorker about Tyrone Hood</a>, who had been convicted of murder in 1996 and sentenced to 75 years in prison. Schmidle’s article included evidence strongly suggesting that Hood was innocent.</p><p data-block-key=\"f540u\">In January 2015, outgoing Illinois governor Pat Quinn <a href=\"https://chicago.cbslocal.com/2015/01/13/quinn-commutes-sentence-of-man-convicted-of-lying-in-murder-case/\">commuted the prison sentences</a> of a number of prisoners, including Hood, on his last day in office. Because Hood received a commutation, not a pardon, he was let out of jail early but the murder conviction stayed on his record.</p><p data-block-key=\"lupo9\">At the time, a spokeswoman for Cook County State Attorney Anita Alvarez told CBS 2 Chicago that Alvarez was “deeply disappointed” with the governor’s decision to commute Hood’s sentence.</p><p data-block-key=\"zcxdt\">Just a month later, though, Alvarez’s office announced that its Conviction Integrity Unit had completed a two-year investigation into Hood’s case, which concluded that Hood’s conviction should be vacated. Alvarez then <a href=\"https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-tyrone-hood-conviction-dismissed-met-0210-20150209-story.html\">asked a court to vacate Hood’s conviction</a>, which the court did. Hood was now out of prison and cleared of the murder conviction.</p><p data-block-key=\"183az\">In 2016, Hood filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the city of Chicago and a number of Chicago police officers, accusing them of pressuring witnesses into falsely accusing him of murder.</p><p data-block-key=\"uzar6\">On Feb. 22, 2019, the defendants’ attorneys mailed the reporter Schmidle a document subpoena. The <a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/15957074/1/4/hood-v-city-of-chicago/\">extremely broad subpoena</a> ordered him to turn over, among other things, “All Documents Nicholas Schmidle received from any person or entity in connection with researching, investigating, preparing or publishing any of the Articles” about Hood. Schmidle’s attorneys <a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/15957074/1/5/hood-v-city-of-chicago/\">objected to the subpoena</a> on March 13, and the defendants seemed to drop it.</p><p data-block-key=\"uqy29\">In June 2019, Schmidle was served with <a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/15957074/1/6/hood-v-city-of-chicago/\">a subpoena to testify in the case</a> and a <a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/15957074/1/7/hood-v-city-of-chicago/\">second, more complete copy</a> of the same subpoena a week later.</p><p data-block-key=\"zoh0b\">Attorneys for both Hood and Schmidle have opposed the subpoenas for the reporter, arguing that a journalist’s documents and testimony are not relevant to a case that concerns the alleged behavior of Chicago police officers in the early 1990s.</p><p data-block-key=\"rmzst\">Attorneys for the city of Chicago’s attorneys and the other defendants in Hood’s civil rights have argued that Schmidle’s testimony is essential, using a theory that puts Schmidle at the center of the action.</p><p data-block-key=\"8nmo7\">The defendants’ attorneys have argued that Hood’s civil rights were not violated because he actually is guilty of murder and his murder conviction should not have been vacated. They argue that journalists like Schmidle were tricked into writing a false narrative, which in turn prompted Governor Quinn to commute Hood’s sentence and pressure the state attorney’s office to get Hood’s conviction thrown out.</p><p data-block-key=\"lbfxd\">The current status of the Feb. 22 document subpoena is somewhat unclear. After Schmidle’s attorneys objected to the subpoena in March, the defendants never moved to compel Schmidle to turn over the documents. In effect, they dropped the subpoena. But on July 10, Schmidle received another copy of the document subpoena by email. Once again, Schmidle refused to turn over the documents and the defendants didn’t bother to press the matter.</p><p data-block-key=\"71nyx\">Schmidle’s attorneys did not ask the judge to quash the document subpoena, but only because it seemed like the defendants had already given up on that one.</p><p data-block-key=\"fw0oo\">“Defendants have not moved to compel responses to the Document Subpoena, and therefore it is not at issue in this motion,” they wrote in the July 23 motion to quash the deposition subpoenas. That motion to quash was granted<a href=\"https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/15957074/12/hood-v-city-of-chicago/\"> in October</a>.</p><p data-block-key=\"iiqbd\">Through a New Yorker spokeswoman, Schmidle declined to comment.</p></div>",
"introduction": "",
"teaser": "",
"teaser_image": "https://media.pressfreedomtracker.us/media/images/Screen_Shot_2019-11-08_at_12.56.4.2e16d0ba.fill-1330x880.jpg",
"primary_video": null,
"image_caption": "<p data-block-key=\"r1cik\">A portion of the subpoena outlining broad requests for reporter Nicholas Schmidle's work product</p>",
"arresting_authority": null,
"arrest_status": null,
"release_date": null,
"detention_date": null,
"unnecessary_use_of_force": false,
"case_number": null,
"case_type": null,
"status_of_seized_equipment": null,
"is_search_warrant_obtained": false,
"actor": null,
"border_point": null,
"target_us_citizenship_status": null,
"denial_of_entry": false,
"stopped_previously": false,
"did_authorities_ask_for_device_access": null,
"did_authorities_ask_about_work": null,
"assailant": null,
"was_journalist_targeted": null,
"charged_under_espionage_act": false,
"subpoena_type": "journalist communications or work product",
"name_of_business": null,
"third_party_business": null,
"legal_order_venue": "Federal",
"status_of_prior_restraint": null,
"mistakenly_released_materials": false,
"links": [],
"equipment_seized": [],
"equipment_broken": [],
"state": {
"name": "Illinois",
"abbreviation": "IL"
},
"updates": [],
"case_statuses": [],
"workers_whose_communications_were_obtained": [],
"target_nationality": [],
"targeted_institutions": [],
"tags": [],
"politicians_or_public_figures_involved": [],
"authors": [],
"categories": [
"Subpoena/Legal Order"
],
"targeted_journalists": [
"Nicholas Schmidle (The New Yorker)"
],
"subpoena_statuses": [
"dropped"
],
"type_of_denial": null
}
]
